Buildings envelope anomalies: A visual survey methodology
Source abstract
Abstract
Abstract The early deterioration of social housing envelopes reflect their low durability. An evaluation methodology to estimate social housing envelope degradation level was developed which has been applied to a set of social housing. Following this study, the methodology revealed adequate for any sort of buildings, taking into account their specific features that necessitate some methodology modifications. To support the visual survey of the external building envelope, tables applying the Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) were used to analyse the principal causes and effects of the anomalies identified. To evaluate the main visible anomalies on their external envelope, two evaluation scales have been created: one for the degradation degree applicable to each typified anomaly and the other for the performance level of each building respect to a set of functional requirements. The degradation level of each of the principal anomalies was determined as well as the evaluation index of the building envelope. Degradation evaluation results were obtained through visual survey and were aggregated by two methods developed for the research: one based on the Hermione aggregation method and the other on the results of the inquiry to tenants based on a multi-attribute analysis attending to the relatively importance (weight) of the evaluated requirements. Each attributed weight was obtained throughout the expressed opinion of technicians and specialists from the construction sector. The aim of this paper is to present the visual survey methodology of the envelope degradation level and the results obtained for the degradation degree of each typified anomaly, and the performance level of each building in respect of a set of functional requirements.
Source: openaire · Quality: candidate unverified · Source record ↗
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Facilities and Workplace Management · Sustainable Building Design and Assessment
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
References (40)
Show source-provided references
1. Deterioration of European apartment buildings10.1016/j.enbuild.2004.09.010 ↗
2. 3ª Análise Retrospectiva do Parque Habitacional Financiado pelo INH anos de 1995 a 1998. LNEC, Relatório 239/04 – NAU, Lisboa, Portugal; 2004.
3. The English edition of principal guide for service life planning of buildings. Architectural Institute of Japan; 1993.
4. Hovde J. Factor methods for service life prediction state of the art. CIB W080/RILEM 175 SLM: service life methodologies prediction of service life for buildings and components. task group performance based methods for service life prediction; 2004. .
5. Censos 2001: resultados definitivos: XIV recenseamento geral da população: IV recenseamento geral da habitação. INE, 1° volume, Lisboa, Portugal; 2001-a.
6. Censos 2001. Análise de resultados. Lisboa (Portugal): INE; 2001. .
7. Rodrigues MFS. Estado de Conservação de Edifícios de Habitação a Custos Controlados. Índice de avaliação e metodologia para a sua obtenção, Tese de Doutoramento, Universidade de Aveiro, Portugal, Aveiro; 2008.
8. Harris · 2001
9. Sarja A et al. Lifetime engineering of buildings and civil infrastructures. European guide for life time design and management of civil infrastructures and buildings. Project cluster lifetime. Technical Research Centre of Finland, VTT. VTT Building and Transport; 2005. .
10. Watt · 1999
11. ISO 6241:1984 (F). Normes de performance dans le bâtiment – príncipes d‘établissement et facteurs à considérer.
12. ISO 15686-1:2000. Building and constructed assets – service life planning – Part 1: general principles.
13. Patologia de la construcción en España: aproximacion estadistica
14. Henriques · 2001
15. Qualité, progressons ensemble. Bilan 1995–2005. Agence Qualité Construction. Observatoire de la Qualité de la Construction; 2006.
16. Common defects in low-rise traditional housing. Digest 268. Building research establishment. Garston; 1988.
17. Database analysis – report 4. Construction quality forum, Garston; April 1997.
18. Housing association property mutual feedback from data 1991–1994. Technical note no. 7, London, United Kingdom; 1997.
19. Trotman P. An examination of the BRE Advisory Service database compiled from property inspections. Paper presented of the dealing with defects in building symposium, CIB/ICITE-CNR/DISET, Varena, Italy; 1994.
20. A quantitative model for efficient maintenance of plastered and painted facades
21. Censos 2001. Antecedentes, Metodologia e Conceitos: Censos 2001: XIV recenseamento geral da população: IV recenseamento geral da habitação. Lisboa (Portugal): INE; 2003.
22. Método de avaliação do estado de conservação de edifícios. Instruções de aplicação e ficha de avaliação. Ministério das Obras Públicas, Transportes e Comunicações. Lisboa (Portugal): LNEC; 2006.
23. Guide Socotec de la Maintenance et de la Réhabilitation. Fiche 5.04. Groupe Moniteur; 2002.
24. Gaspar PL et al. Técnicas de Diagnóstico e Classificação de Fissuração em Fachadas Rebocadas. PATORREB 2006. Porto (Portugal): FEUP; 2006. p. 541–50.
25. Gaspar PL, Brito J. Assessment of the overall degradation level of an element, based on the field data. 10th international conference on durability of building material and components. Paper TT8 – 68, Lyon, France; 2005.
26. Lounis et al. Effective decision-making tools for roofing maintenance management. In: Miresco Edmont T, editor. Proceedings of the first international conference on new information technologies for decision making in construction. Montreal; 1998. p. 425–36.
27. Marteinsson B, Jónsson B. Overall survey of buildings – performance and maintenance. iN: 8th international conference on durability of building material and components. Canada: Vancouver; 1999. p. 1634–54.
28. Teo Eal. An assessment of factors affecting the service life of external paint finish on plastered facades. In: 10th international conference on durability of building material and components. Paper TT4 – 152, Lyon, France; 2005. p. 17–20.
29. Service life prediction of exterior cladding components under failure conditions
30. EPIQR. Les principes de la méthode; 2004. .
31. EPIQR and IEQ: indoor environment quality in European apartment buildings10.1016/S0378-7788(99)00024-9 ↗
32. Lair J, Chevalier JL. Failure mode effect and criticality analysis for risk analysis (design) and maintenance planning (exploitation). In: 9th international conference on durability of building material and components. Paper 032, Brisbane, Australia; 2002. p. 17–21.
33. CIB W080. Prediction of service life for buildings and components. CIB report: publication 310. State of the art report on failure modes effects and criticality analysis. Research for and application to the building domain; March 2006.
34. Mertz C, Flourentzou F, Gay JB. ALBATROS, Méthode d´aide à la décision intégrant les enjeux du développement durable en phase de planification d´un project de construction publique, 2005, available at www.eco-bau.ch/francais/.
35. ISO 15686-3: 2002. Building and constructed assets – Service life planning – Part 3: Performance audits and reviews.
36. Sarja, A. Lifetime Engineering of Buildings and Civil Infrastructures Deliverable 3.1: Generic description of lifetime engineering of buildings, civil and industrial infrastructures. Second draft 26.08.2005. Technical Research Centre of Finland, VTT. VTT Building and Transport, 2005, available at http://lifetime.vtt.fi/lifetime_deliverable_3_1.pdf.
37. Pereira, S. Levantamento dos Principais Aspectos que Influenciam a qualidade dos Edifícios de Habitação em TMAD. Dissertação apresentada à Universidade de Trás-os-Montes e Alto Douro para obtenção do Grau de Mestre em Tecnologias das Engenharias, Portugal, Vila Real, 2004.
38. MCDM-23. Multi-Criteria Decision-Making. A Method for specifying and priorising criteria and goals in design. International Energy Agency – Solar Heating and Cooling Programme. Task 23. Optimization of solar energy use in large buildings. Subtask C. Fevereiro 2002, available at www.iea-shcp.org/task23/download/MCDM_booklet.pdf.
39. Saaty · 1980
40. Yannou B; Limayem F. Méthodes de comparaisons par paires pour la pondération en groupe, 2002, available at www.mktools.com/bibliographie.html.