journal article·2013-08

Practical implementation of the durability index performance-based design approach

G. Nganga, Mark Alexander, Hans Beushausen

Publisher page

Abstract

Abstract The paper provides a summary of findings from a study that was done to evaluate practicality of Durability Index (DI) performance-based specifications that have been implemented on a large scale in a major infrastructure project involving bridge and other structures in Gauteng Province, South Africa. The practicality of the approach was evaluated by considering: the magnitude and variability in DI test values (Oxygen Permeability Index, OPI, and water sorptivity) and cover depths; applicability of the DI tests in laboratories to determine if correct execution of test procedures is done, in addition to its application on site where samples are obtained; and response of the industry to this recently implemented approach which was assessed from reviewing responses to a questionnaire that was sent out to resident engineers (REs). From the statistical analysis, it was observed that the average values of the durability parameters (OPI, sorptivity and cover depth) in all cases complied with the limiting minimum values. However, for some structures, a high proportion of individual DI test results failed to comply with limiting values. The variability observed in the coefficient of permeability (k) and sorptivity values was high. For cover depth readings the variability measured on structures cast in situ was considerably higher than for precast elements. A mixed perception of the effects of this approach was obtained among engineers; some indicated that it had no effect on construction practices while others felt that, as a result of the performance-based project specifications, stricter controls had been placed in execution of construction practices. From this study it was concluded that the DI performance-based approach offers a potentially useful and practical way to perform quality control of cover concrete. However, certain limitations have to still be overcome to fully reap the potential benefits of this approach. These include high variability in test results (sorptivity, coefficient of permeability), poor quality of test panels, poor communication between site staff and laboratories, difficulties in transport of test panels.
Source: openaire · Quality: candidate unverified · Source record ↗

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Infrastructure Maintenance and Monitoring · Concrete Corrosion and Durability · Construction Project Management and Performance

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

References (31)

Show source-provided references
1. Richardson · 2002
2. Performance-based specifications for concrete
3. Performance specifications for durable concrete
4. van Breugel K. Key factors for producing durable concrete structures. In: Kovler K, editor. International RILEM-JCI seminar on concrete durability and service life planning. 14–16 March, 2006. France: RILEM Publications. p. 302–309.10.1617/291214390X.032 ↗
5. Material performance lessons10.1016/j.cemconres.2007.09.009 ↗
6. Performance standards and specifications for concrete: recent Canadian developments
7. ASTM, C 1202-05. Standard test method for electrical indication of concrete’s ability to resist chloride ion penetration. vol. 04:02. ASTM, International; 2007.
8. Polder RB, van der Wegen G, Boutz M. Performance based guideline for service life design of concrete for Civil Engineering Structures – a proposal discussed in the Netherlands. In: Baroghel-Bouny V, Andrade C, Torrent R, Scrivener K, editors. International RILEM workshop on performance based evaluation and indicators for concrete durability. 19–21 March, 2006. France: RILEM. 31–39.
9. DuraCrete. Probabilistic performance based durability design of concrete structures, final technical report. The European Union – Brite Euram III. 2000. 144p.
10. Baroghel-Bouny V. Evaluation and prediction of reinforced concrete durability by means of durability indicators. Part I: New performance-based approach. In: Kovler K, editor. International RILEM-JCI seminar on concrete durability and service life planning. 14–16 March, 2006. France: RILEM Publications. 259.10.1617/291214390X.028 ↗
11. Torrent R. Performance-based specification and conformity control of durability. In: Baroghel-Bouny V, Andrade C, Torrent R, Scrivener K, editors. Performance based evaluation and indicators for concrete durability. 19–21 March, 2006. France: RILEM. p. 41–50.
12. BS EN 206-1. Concrete – Part 1: Specification, performance, production and conformity. London. British Standard Institute; 2000.
13. ACI 318M-08: Building code requirements for structural concrete, vol. 318. ACI Committee; 2008. 473p.
14. Arskog V, Sengul O, Gjorv OE. Performance-based quality control for concrete durability. In: Baroghel-Bouny V, Andrade C, Torrent R, Scrivener K, editors. Performance based evaluation and indicators for concrete durability, 19–21 March, 2006. France: RILEM. p. 223–227.
15. A framework for use of durability indexes in performance-based design and specifications for reinforced concrete structures10.1617/s11527-007-9295-0 ↗
16. Use of durability indexes to achieve durable cover concrete in reinforced concrete structures
17. Alexander MG. Durability Indexes and their use in Concrete Engineering. In: Kovler K, Marchand J, Mindess S, Weiss J, editors. Proceedings, international RILEM symposium: concrete science and engineering, a tribute to arnon bentur. March, 2004. RILEM, PRO 36.9-22.10.1617/2912143586.002 ↗
18. The South African durability index tests in an international comparison
19. Beushausen H, Alexander M. The South African performance-based approach for specification and control of concrete durability. Performance-based specifications for concrete. fib Workshop, Leipzig, Germany, June 2011. p. 301–10.
20. Ballim Y. Towards an early-age index for the durability of concrete. International conference concrete 2000 economic and durable construction through excellence. Dhir RK, Jones MR, editor. London: E & FN SPON. 1003-1012; 1993.
21. Mackechnie · 1999
22. Salvoldi · 2010
23. Mackechnie JR. Predictions of reinforced concrete durability in the marine environment. PhD thesis. University of Cape Town; 1996.
24. Muigai RN, Moyo P, Alexander MG, Beushausen HD. Application of durability indexes in probabilistic modelling for chloride ingress of RC members. In: Kovler K, editor. Concrete durability and Service life planning – ConcreteLife’09. 7–9 September, 2009. France: RILEM. pp. 408–416.
25. Mackechnie JR, Alexander MG. Durability predictions using early-age durability index testing. In: 9th Durability and building materials conference. Brisbane: Australian Corrosion Association; 2002.
26. The South African National Roads Agency Limited, (SANRAL). Project document: project specifications; 2010.
27. Ronny R, Everitt P. Durability specification and testing results from four bridge structures in Kwa Zulu-Natal 2010. In: Concrete for a sustainable environment, 3–4 August 2010. Emperor’s Palace, Kempton Park, Gauteng, South Africa.
28. Beushausen H, Knecht J, Alexander M, Schubert K. Performance-based durability control for precast concrete elements. In: The 3rd FIB international congress May–June 2010, Washington, USA.
29. Assessing the repeatability and reproducibility values of South African durability index tests
30. Increased cover specifications in IS 456: 2000 – crack-width implications in RC slabs
31. Navidi · 2008