journal article·1992-07

Quantitative Fiber Mixture Analysis by Scanning Electron Microscopy

F.-J. Wortmann, G. Wortmann

Textile Research Journal· Volume 62· Issue 7
Publisher page

Abstract

Labeling textile blends requires identification and quantification of their fibrous components. Blends of specialty animal fibers with sheep's wool are of special, practical importance; for these the light microscope is the traditional tool of analysis. To investigate the actual applicability of light microscopy for analyzing such blends as an alternative to the scanning electron microscope (SEM), we analyzed in detail the results of round trials conducted in the seventies. The results confirm that light microscopy, in general, is neither an objective nor a reproducible method for analyzing wool/specialty fiber blends. Though there was substantial progress with subsequent round trials, the data suggest that there is a fundamental statistical limit to the pass/fail rate, i.e., the ratio of correct versus incorrect analyses in a round trial that can be achieved by light microscopy. Even allowing for generous error limits, this effect leaves an intolerable element of chance for the correctness of analysis. Such performance is in pronounced contrast to that of the SEM method, where round trials have shown that laboratories that perform well reach analysis errors for specialty fiber/wool blends that are within or close to the natural error limits of microscopic analyses.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Electron and X-Ray Spectroscopy Techniques

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Deutsches Wollforschungsinstitut, Aachen, Germany

References (44)

Show source-provided references
1. AATCC Test Method 20A, Fiber Analysis · Quantitative AATCC Technical Manual · 1990 · 65 · 67
2. American Society for Testing and Materials · 1978
3. Appleyard H. M. · 1960
4. Blankenburg G. · Melliand Textilber. · 1978 · 59 · 974
5. Bauters M. · Bull. Sci. Inst. Textil Fr. · 1981 · 10 · 67
6. Bauters M., Ponchel P., Demarche Analytique dans le Dosage Laine-Mohair par Voie Chimique, in “Proc. Int. Wool Textile Org. Conf.” Techn. Comm. rep. no. 3, Paris, January 1982.
7. Berndt H. · Schriftenr. Dtsch. Wollf. Inst. · 1990 · 106 · 259
8. Brach J., Rousseau L., Etude de la Precision de la Methode Lanametrique d'Estimation des Pourcentages Ponderaux d'Angora Dans les Melanges, in “Proc. Int. Wool Textile Org. Conf.” Techn. Comm. rep. no. 22, Oostende, June 1986.
9. Derminot J. · 1973
10. EEC Working Party on Textile Names and Labelling—Analysis · J. Textile Inst. · 1988 · 79 · 15510.1080/00405008808659134 ↗
11. Gallico L., Rapport sur les résultats des essais interlaboratoires (réunion de Paris, January 25–27, 1982), in “Proc. Int. Wool Textile Org. Conf.” Techn. Comm., Venice, June 1982.
12. Gaudette B. D., A Collaborative Study in Forensic Hair Comparison, Presented at Int. Assoc. Forens. Sci. Conf., Oxford, 1984.
13. Natrella Gibbons M., Experimental Statistics, Nat. Bureau of Standards Handbook 91, U.S. Dept. Commerce, 1963.10.6028/NBS.HB.91 ↗
14. 10.1111/j.1478-4408.1990.tb00072.x10.1111/j.1478-4408.1990.tb00072.x ↗
15. Greaves P. · Eur. Micros. Anal. · 1991 · 13 · 41
16. Hamlyn P. F. · Schriftenr. Dtsch. Wollf. Inst. · 1990 · 106 · 249
17. Höcker H. · Methods of Analysis of Animal Fibers at DWI—State of the Art · 1990 · 2 · 374
18. 10.1177/00405175870570110910.1177/004051758705701109 ↗
19. 10.1016/S0015-7368(76)71066-110.1016/S0015-7368(76)71066-1 ↗
20. Körner A. · Schriftenr. Dtsch. Wollf. Inst. · 1988 · 103 · 104
21. Kusch P. · Schriftenr. Dtsch. Wollf. Inst. · 1984 · 96
22. 10.1177/00405175840540021110.1177/004051758405400211 ↗
23. Meyer-Stork L. S. · Textilveredlung · 1988 · 23 · 304
24. Nelson G., Hamlyn P. F., McCarthy B. J., Developments in DNA-Based Specialty Fiber Analysis, in “Proc. 8th Int. Wool Textile Res. Conf.” Christchurch, NZ, vol. II, 1990 pp. 385–401.
25. Parisot A. · 1971
26. Sich J. · Schriftenr. Dtsch. Wollf. Inst. · 1990 · 106 · 91
27. Sich J. · Textile Chem. Color. · 1990 · 22 · 23
28. Smuts S., Hunter L., Gee E., The Identification of Mohair in Blends with Other Animal Fibers Using their Factional Properties, South African Wool Textile Res. Inst., Techn. rep. no. 457, 1980.
29. Taylor J. K. · 1987
30. Tucker D. J. · Integral Lipids of Goat Fibers · 1990 · 2 · 364
31. Weaver J. W. · 1984
32. Wildman A. B. · 1954
33. 10.1177/00405175860560070810.1177/004051758605600708 ↗
34. Wortmann F.J., Freddi G., Analyse von Wolle/Edelhaarmischungen mittels Rasterelektronenmikroskopie, Erste Ergebnisse des Rundversuchs, in “Proc. Int. Wool Textile Org. Conf.” rep. no. 6, Palm Beach, 1988.
35. 10.1177/00405175890590020310.1177/004051758905900203 ↗
36. 10.1080/0040500890865831810.1080/00405008908658318 ↗
37. Wortmann F.-J. · Schriftenr. Dtsch. Wollf. Inst. · 1990 · 106 · 113
38. 10.1177/00405175910610070110.1177/004051759106100701 ↗
39. Wortmann F.-J. · Textile Res. J.
40. Wortmann G., Körner A., Wortmann F.J., Beitrag zur elektrophoretischen Differenzierung feiner Tierhaare, in “Proc. Int. Wool Textile Org. Conf.” Techn. Comm. rep. no. 10, Paris, 1986.
41. Wortmann G. · Schriftenr. Dtsch. Wollf. Inst. · 1988 · 103 · 39
42. Wortmann G. · Schriftenr. Dtsch. Wollf. Inst. · 1990 · 106 · 138
43. Wortmann G. · Schriftenr. Dtsch. Wollf. Inst. · 1990 · 106 · 269
44. Zar J. H. · 1984