journal article·2025-08Open access

Optimizing Plasma Spraying Process Parameters for Tungsten Coatings Used in Fusion Reactors

G. Schmidtmann, Y. J. Sohn, A. Litnovsky, M. Rasinski, R. Vaßen, J. W. Coenen, S. Brezinsek, Ch. Linsmeier, O. Guillon, G. Mauer

Abstract

Abstract The quality of low-pressure plasma-sprayed tungsten (W) coatings for application in fusion reactors was investigated under various spray process parameter settings for the following substrate materials: carbon fiber composite, Eurofer (a ferritic/martensitic steel with reduced activation), and tungsten. The deposited coatings with a thickness of approximately 130 µm were evaluated in terms of porosity, deposition efficiency, defects, and surface roughness. Selected parameter sets were applied to produce scaled-up coatings up to 500 µm in thickness on Eurofer and tungsten substrates. Regions of very low porosity of approx. 0.3% and varying grain appearance were found. However, the subsequent grain size evaluation in terms of the aspect ratio of the fitted ellipse and the maximum Feret diameter did not reveal any significant differences in grain structure through the coating regions. The residual stress measurements performed by XRD using the sin2(Ψ) method validated the thermal stresses within the coatings resulting from the thermal mismatch between the coating and the substrate during cooling. The results indicate that the process settings and spraying process were effective in reducing residual stresses and producing coatings suitable for future fusion-relevant applications.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Advanced materials and composites · Fusion materials and technologies · Nuclear Materials and Properties

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

References (61)

Show source-provided references
1. P.C. Stangeby, The plasma boundary of magnetic fusion devices, Institute of Physics Publishing, Bristol and Philadelphia, 2000.10.1201/9780367801489 ↗
2. G. van Oost, Ed., Fundamentals of Magnetic Fusion Technology, International Atomic Energy Agency, 2023
3. A. Litnovsky, I. Duran, J.W. Coenen, Y. Gasparyan, M.R. Gilbert, E. Hollmann, C. Linsmeier, S. Nogami, C.H. Skinner and S. Zinkle, Fusion—Reactor Materials, Elsevier, Encyclopedia of Nuclear Energy, 2021, p 594–619
4. J. Boscary, G. Ehrke, P. Frosi, P. Junghanns, B. Končar, B. Mendelevitch, D. Naujoks, R. Neu, M. Richou, L. Selan, J. Tretter, Z. Wang, J.H. You and K. Zhang, Conceptual design of the next generation of W7-X divertor W-target elements, Fusion Eng. Des., 2023, 192, 113629.10.1016/j.fusengdes.2023.113629 ↗
5. P. Arena, G. Bongiovì, I. Catanzaro, C. Ciurluini, A. Collaku, A. Del Nevo, P.A. Di Maio, M. D’Onorio, F. Giannetti, V. Imbriani, P. Maccari, L. Melchiorri, F. Moro, R. Mozzillo, A. Noce, L. Savoldi, S. Siriano, A. Tassone and M. Utili, Design and integration of the Eu-Demo water-cooled lead lithium breeding blanket, Energies, 2023, 16(4), p 2069.10.3390/en16042069 ↗
6. G. van Oost, A.V. Dedov and V.P. Budaev, The plasma-facing materials of Tokamak thermonuclear reactors: requirements, thermal stabilization, and tests (a review), Therm. Eng., 2021, 68(3), p 185–200.10.1134/S0040601521030095 ↗
7. T. Donné, W. Morris, X. Litaudon, C. Hidalgo, D. McDonald, H. Zohm, E. Diegele, A. Mòslang, K. Nordlund, and G. Federici, European Research Roadmap to the Realisation of Fusion Energy 2018
8. F. Maviglia, C. Bachmann, G. Federici, T. Franke, M. Siccinio, R. Albanese, R. Ambrosino, W. Arter, R. Bonifetto, G. Calabrò, R. de Luca, L.-E. Di Grazia, E. Fable, P. Fanelli, A. Fanni, M. Firdaouss, J. Gerardin, R. Lombroni, M. Mattei, M. Moscheni, W. Morris, G. Pautasso, S. Pestchanyi, G. Ramogida, M.L. Richiusa, G. Sias, F. Subba, F. Villone, J.-H. You and Z. Vizvary, Integrated design strategy for EU-Demo first wall protection from plasma transients, Fusion Eng. Des., 2022, 177, 113067.10.1016/j.fusengdes.2022.113067 ↗
9. T.R. Barrett, G. Ellwood, G. Pérez, M. Kovari, M. Fursdon, F. Domptail, S. Kirk, S.C. McIntosh, S. Roberts, S. Zheng, L.V. Boccaccini, J.-H. You, C. Bachmann, J. Reiser, M. Rieth, E. Visca, G. Mazzone, F. Arbeiter and P.K. Domalapally, Progress in the engineering design and assessment of the European Demo First Wall and Divertor Plasma Facing Components, Fusion Eng. Des., 2016, 109–111, p 917–924.10.1016/j.fusengdes.2016.01.052 ↗
10. K.P. Mingard, The use of EBSD for analysis of additively manufactured materials, 202310.47120/npl.mgpg152 ↗
11. I.C. Noyan and J.B. Cohen, Residual stress: measurement by diffraction and interpretation, Springer, New York, 1987.10.1007/978-1-4613-9570-6 ↗
12. G. Federici, L. Boccaccini, F. Cismondi, M. Gasparotto, Y. Poitevin and I. Ricapito, An overview of the EU breeding blanket design strategy as an integral part of the demo design effort, Fusion Eng. Des., 2019, 141, p 30–42.10.1016/j.fusengdes.2019.01.141 ↗
13. R. Lindau, A. Möslang, M. Rieth, M. Klimiankou, E. Materna-Morris, A. Alamo, A.-A.F. Tavassoli, C. Cayron, A.-M. Lancha, P. Fernandez, N. Baluc, R. Schäublin, E. Diegele, G. Filacchioni, J.W. Rensman, B. Schaaf, E. Lucon and W. Dietz, Present development status of eurofer and ods-eurofer for application in blanket concepts, Fusion Eng. Des., 2005, 75–79, p 989–996.10.1016/j.fusengdes.2005.06.186 ↗
14. G. Pintsuk, J. Compan, J. Linke, P. Majerus, A. Peacock, D. Pitzer and M. Rödig, Mechanical and thermo-physical characterization of the carbon fibre composite Nb31, Phys. Scr., 2007, T128, p 66–71.10.1088/0031-8949/2007/T128/013 ↗
15. R.B. Heimann, Plasma Spray Coating: Principles and applications, 2nd ed., Wiley-VCH, 2008
16. T. Keller, A. Litnovsky, G. Mauer, C. Linsmeier and O. Guillon, Innovative tungsten coatings for an application in modern and future fusion devices, Metals, 2023, 13(3), 531.10.3390/met13030531 ↗
17. T. Zhu, M. Baeva, H. Testrich, T. Kewitz and R. Foest, Effect of a spatially fluctuating heating of particles in a plasma spray process, Plasma Chem. Plasma Process.s., 2023, 43(1), p 1–24.10.1007/s11090-022-10290-y ↗
18. K. Kumar and D. Das, Equilibrium and metastable samarium-cobalt deposits produced by arc plasma spraying, Thin Solid Films, 1978, 54(3), p 263–269.10.1016/0040-6090(78)90382-6 ↗
19. X. Chen, A. Bhattacharyaa, K.D. Linton, Y. Yamamoto, M.A. Sokolov, L.N. Clowers, and Y. Katoh, Mechanical Properties and Microstructure Characterization of Unirradiated Eurofer-97 Steel Variants For the Eurofusion Project, Fusion Eng. Des, 2019(146)10.2172/1471901 ↗
20. M. Rieth, M. Schirra, A. Falkenstein, P. Graf, S. Heger, H. Kempe, R. Lindau, and H. Zimmermann, EUROFER 97. Tensile, charpy, creep and structural tests, 2003
21. R. Vassen, Jülich Thermal Spray Center (Jtsc) - a new research and innovation infrastructure of Forschungszentrum Jülich, Ceram. Forum Int., 2020, 97, p 22.
22. K. Siebertz, D. van Bebber and T. Hochkirchen, Statistische Versuchsplanung, Springer, Berlin Heidelberg, 2017.10.1007/978-3-662-55743-3 ↗
23. C.A. Schneider, W.S. Rasband and K.W. Eliceiri, Nih image to ImageJ: 25 years of image analysis, Nat. Methods, 2012, 9(7), p 671–675.10.1038/nmeth.2089 ↗
24. M.I. Boulos, P.L. Fauchais, and J.V. Heberlein, Thermal Spray Fundamentals, Springer International Publishing, 202110.1007/978-3-030-70672-2 ↗
25. V.M. Hauk and E. Macherauch, A useful guide for X-ray stress evaluation (Xse), Adv. X-ray Anal., 1983, 27, p 81–99.
26. I.C. Noyan and J.B. Cohen, Residual Stress – Springer Series on Materials Research and Engineering, Edited By B. Ilschner and N. J. Grant. Springer‐Verlag, New York‐Berlin‐Heidelberg‐London‐Paris‐Tokyo 1987, 276 Seiten, 160 Bilder, 31 Tabellen, Dm 138. –, Isbn 3‐540‐96378‐2: Measurement by diffraction and interpretation, Cryst. Res. Technol., 1989, 24(2)10.1002/crat.2170240228 ↗
27. J. Goulden, A. Bewick and P. Trimby, Developments in Aztec: new solutions for EBSd, Microsc. Microanal.l., 2017, 23(S1), p 22–23.10.1017/S1431927617000794 ↗
28. R.S. Lima, Porous aps ysz tbc manufactured at high powder feed rate (100 G/Min) and deposition efficiency (70%): microstructure, Bond Strength Thermal Gradients, J. Therm. Spray Tech., 2022, 31(3), p 396–414.10.1007/s11666-021-01302-y ↗
29. N. Curry, M. Leitner and K. Körner, High-porosity thermal barrier coatings from high-power plasma spray equipment—processing, performance and economics, Coatings, 2020, 10(10), 957.10.3390/coatings10100957 ↗
30. G. Mauer and R. Vaßen, Plasma spraying porous thermal barrier coatings with high deposition efficiency: a solvable dilemma?, Surf. Coat. Technol., 2022, 451, 129070.10.1016/j.surfcoat.2022.129070 ↗
31. M. Mathanbabu, D. Thirumalaikumarasamy, M. Tamilselvi and S. Kumar, Optimization of plasma spray process variables to attain the minimum porosity and maximum hardness of the Lz/Ysz thermal barrier coatings utilizing the response surface approach, Mater. Res. Express, 2022, 9(9), p 96505.10.1088/2053-1591/ac8857 ↗
32. K. Szymkiewicz, M. Góral, T. Kubaszek, and K. Gancarczyk, Effect of Plasma Spraying Parameters on Microstructure and Thickness and Porosity of Wc-Crc-Ni Coatings Deposited on Titanium, KM, 2023, 61(4)10.31577/km.2023.4.223 ↗
33. S.Y. Moon, C.H. Choi, H.S. Kim, P. Oh, B.G. Hong, S.K. Kim and D.W. Lee, Thick tungsten coating on ferritic–martensitic steel applied with a vacuum plasma spray coating method, Surf. Coat. Technol., 2015, 280, p 225–231.10.1016/j.surfcoat.2015.09.008 ↗
34. A.A. Sorour, A.Y. Adesina, M.A. Hussein and B.F. Al-Daajani, Effect of powder feed rate of plasma-sprayed Fe–Cr–Mo–B–C coatings on microstructure, tribology and corrosion in 3.5% NaCl solution, Arab. J. Sci. Eng., 2022, 47(7), p 9271–9285.10.1007/s13369-022-06756-y ↗
35. U. Hudomalj, E.F. Sichani, L. Weiss, M. Nabavi and K. Wegener, Effect of particle size distribution width on repeatability of coating characteristics in atmospheric plasma spraying, Procedia CIRP, 2022, 113, p 530–535.10.1016/j.procir.2022.09.180 ↗
36. J. Matějíček, M. Vilémová, B. Nevrlá, L. Kocmanová, J. Veverka, M. Halasová and H. Hadraba, The influence of substrate temperature and spraying distance on the properties of plasma sprayed tungsten and steel coatings deposited in a shrouding chamber, Surf. Coat. Technol., 2017, 318, p 217–223.10.1016/j.surfcoat.2016.10.055 ↗
37. K. Bobzin, H. Heinemann and S.R. Dokhanchi, Development of an expert system for prediction of deposition efficiency in plasma spraying, J. Therm. Spray Tech., 2023, 32(2–3), p 643–656.10.1007/s11666-022-01494-x ↗
38. R. Vaßen, K.-H. Rauwald, O. Guillon, J. Aktaa, T. Weber, H.C. Back, D. Qu and J. Gibmeier, Vacuum plasma spraying of functionally graded tungsten/Eurofer97 coatings for fusion applications, Fusion Eng. Des., 2018, 133, p 148–156.10.1016/j.fusengdes.2018.06.006 ↗
39. M. Firdaouss, C. Desgranges, C. Hernandez, C. Mateus, H. Maier, B. Böswirth, H. Greuner, F. Samaille, J. Bucalossi and M. Missirlian, Tungsten coating by ATC plasma spraying on CFC for West Tokamak, Phys. Scr., 2017, T170, p 14008.10.1088/1402-4896/aa8785 ↗
40. T. Hirai, N. Bekris, J.P. Coad, C. Grisolia, J. Linke, H. Maier, G.F. Matthews, V. Philipps and E. Wessel, Failure modes of vacuum plasma spray tungsten coating created on carbon fibre composites under thermal loads, J. Nucl. Mater., 2009, 392(1), p 40–44.10.1016/j.jnucmat.2009.03.060 ↗
41. C. Ruset, E. Grigore, D. Falie, M. Gherendi, H. Maier, M. Rasinski, G.F. Matthews and V. Zoita, The impact of thermal fatigue and carbidization on the W coatings deposited on CFC tiles for the ITER-like wall project at JET, Fusion Eng. Des., 2013, 88(9–10), p 1690–1693.10.1016/j.fusengdes.2013.02.017 ↗
42. T.-S. Jun, S.Y. Zhang, G. Thomas, P. Grant and A. Korsunsky, A study of residual stresses in vacuum plasma sprayed tungsten coatings, Powder Diffr., 2008, 23(2), p 185.10.1154/1.2951792 ↗
43. M.R. Gilbert and J.-C. Sublet, Handbook of activation, transmutation, and radiation damage properties of the elements simulated using FISPACT-II & TENDL-2015; Magnetic Fusion Plants, 2016
44. G. Huot and V. Fellmann, Eds., Chemical Vapor Deposition of Tungsten Coatings on X-Ray Rotating Light Anodes Made of Carbon-Based Materials, 18th Plansee Seminar, 2013
45. C. Ruset, E. Grigore, H. Maier, R. Neu, X. Li, H. Dong, R. Mitteau and X. Courtois, Tungsten coatings deposited on CFC tiles by the combined magnetron sputtering and ion implantation technique, Phys. Scr., 2007, T128, p 171–174.10.1088/0031-8949/2007/T128/033 ↗
46. S. Heuer, J.W. Coenen, G. Pintsuk, J. Matějíček, M. Vilémová and C. Linsmeier, Overview of challenges and developments in joining tungsten and steel for future fusion reactors, Phys. Scr., 2020, T171, p 14028.10.1088/1402-4896/ab47a4 ↗
47. V. Ganesh, D. Dorow-Gerspach, M. Bram, C. Linsmeier, J. Matejicek and M. Vilemova, High heat flux testing of graded W-steel joining concepts for the first wall, Energies, 2023, 16(9), p 3664.10.3390/en16093664 ↗
48. S. Heuer, T. Lienig, A. Mohr, T. Weber, G. Pintsuk, J.W. Coenen, F. Gormann, W. Theisen and C. Linsmeier, Ultra-fast sintered functionally graded Fe/W composites for the first wall of future fusion reactors, Compos. Part B Eng., 2019, 164, p 205–214.10.1016/j.compositesb.2018.11.078 ↗
49. G. Mauer, K.-H. Rauwald and Y.J. Sohn, Tungsten-steel functionally graded coatings for nuclear fusion applications manufactured by cold gas spraying, J. Therm. Spray Technol., 2023, 32(2–3), p 375–387.10.1007/s11666-022-01503-z ↗
50. L. Forest, L.V. Boccaccini, L. Cogneau, A.L. Puma, H. Neuberger, S. Pascal, J. Rey, N. Thomas, J. Tosi and M. Zmitko, Test blanket modules (Iter) and breeding blanket (Demo): history of major fabrication technologies development of Hcll and Hcpb and status, Fusion Eng. Des., 2020, 154, 111493.10.1016/j.fusengdes.2020.111493 ↗
51. T. Grammes, A.K. Mishra, K. Battalov, A. Purwitasari, T. Emmerich and J. Aktaa, Mechanical properties and quality of plasma sprayed, functionally graded tungsten/steel coatings after process upscaling, Mater. Chem. Phys., 2024, 311, p 128530.10.1016/j.matchemphys.2023.128530 ↗
52. J. Pina, A. Dias and J. Lebrun, Study by X-ray diffraction and mechanical analysis of the residual stress generation during thermal spraying, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2003, 347(1–2), p 21–31.10.1016/S0921-5093(02)00580-4 ↗
53. J.H. You, T. Höschen and S. Lindig, Determination of elastic modulus and residual stress of plasma-sprayed tungsten coating on steel substrate, J. Nucl. Mater., 2006, 348(1–2), p 94–101.10.1016/j.jnucmat.2005.09.015 ↗
54. Q. Luo and S. Yang, Uncertainty of the X-ray diffraction (Xrd) sin2 Ψ technique in measuring residual stresses of physical vapor deposition (Pvd) hard coatings, Coatings, 2017, 7(8), 128.10.3390/coatings7080128 ↗
55. G. Thomas, R. Vincent, G. Matthews, B. Dance and P.S. Grant, Interface topography and residual stress distributions in W coatings for fusion armour applications, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2008, 477(1–2), p 35–42.10.1016/j.msea.2007.05.120 ↗
56. S. Hwang and Y. Kim, The effect of grain size and film thickness on the thermal expansion coefficient of copper thin films, J. Nanosci. Nanotechnol., 2011, 11(2), p 1555–1558.10.1166/jnn.2011.3365 ↗
57. T. Grammes, T. Emmerich and J. Aktaa, W/Eurofer functionally graded coatings for plasma facing components: technology transfer to industry and upscaling, Fusion Eng. Des., 2021, 173, 112940.10.1016/j.fusengdes.2021.112940 ↗
58. J. Matějíček, M. Vilémová, R. Mušálek, P. Sachr and J. Horník, The influence of interface characteristics on the adhesion/cohesion of plasma sprayed tungsten coatings, Coatings, 2013, 3(2), p 108–125.10.3390/coatings3020108 ↗
59. K. Murakami, Formation of grain structures of thermal sprayed nickel coatings and the coating properties, MSF, 2005, 502, p 517.10.4028/www.scientific.net/MSF.502.517 ↗
60. L. Hu, B.D. Wirth, and D. Maroudas, Thermal conductivity of tungsten: effects of plasma-related structural defects from molecular-dynamics simulations, Appl. Phys. Lett. 2017, 111(8)10.1063/1.4986956 ↗
61. O. Popov and V. Vishnyakov, The influence of porosity and alloying elements on tungsten-based composites thermal conductivity, J. Nucl. Mater., 2025, 611, 155817.10.1016/j.jnucmat.2025.155817 ↗