journal article·2019-07Open access

A Critical Evaluation of BS PD 7974-7 Structural Fire Response Data Based on USA Fire Statistics

M. Manes, D. Rush

Fire Technology· Volume 55· Issue 4

Abstract

Probabilistic techniques deal with the randomness of variables and reliability of safety system but their application in fire safety engineering is limited due to the lack of data related to real structures subjected to real fires. This can be overcome by analysis of national fire statistics provided by fire departments. Fire statistics databases are a collection of data from real structures subjected to real fires and provides an understanding of real effectiveness of different fire safety measures (i.e. compartmentation) which influence the spread and growth of fire, and ultimately their monetary consequence. The ability to understand the realistic responses of buildings in fire is the fundamental basis of British Standards PD 7974-7, which provides data to perform probabilistic risk assessments for fire. However, the current data presented by BS PD 7974-7:2003 (referred to as PD 7974-7 within this paper) was developed between 1966 and 1987. This research has used the USA fire statistic database of 2014 to recreate the tables present in the PD 7974-7, compare the results, and understand their evolution in time. The comparison between PD 7974-7 and the USA fire statistics introduced in this paper shows that modern fire frequency can be up to more than 10 times smaller than presented in PD 7974-7; area damage in m 2 and spread of fire are linked to automatic extinguish systems effectiveness and greater in the USA fire statistics than predicted by PD 7974-7. This clearly demonstrate the need of updates to PD 7974-7 and feeds towards a better understanding of the robustness, and potentially the resilience, of real structures in fire.
Source: openalex_inverted_index · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Fire dynamics and safety research · Fire effects on concrete materials · Fire effects on ecosystems

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

References (44)

Show source-provided references
1. Hadjisophocleous GV, Benichou N, Tamim AS (1998) Literature review of performance- based fire codes and design environment. J Fire Prot Eng 9(1): 12–4010.1177/104239159800900102 ↗
2. Wang Y, Burgess I, Wald F, Gillie M (2012) Performance-based fire engineering of structures. CRC Press, Boca Raton10.1201/b12076 ↗
3. BSI (2003) PD 7974-7: application of fire safety engineering principles to the design of buildings—Part 7: Probabilistic risk assessment. 3
4. BSI (2012) PD 7974-8:2012: application of fire safety engineering principles to the design of buildings; Part 8: property protection, business and mission continuity, and resilience
5. HM Government (2006) The building regulations 2010 fire safety: approved document B Volume 1—Dwellinghouses
6. HM Government (2006) The building regulations 2010 fire safety approved document B—buildings other than Dwelling Houses
7. BS EN 1992-1-1 (2004) Eurocode 2: design of concrete structures—Part 1-1 : general rules and rules for buildings. Br Stand Inst 1: 230
8. Hopkin D, Van Coile R, Lange D (2017) Certain uncertainty—demonstrating safety in fire engineering design and the need for safety targets. SFPE Europe
9. National Fire Protection Association and National Fire Protection Association. Technical Committee on Uniform Fire Code, “NFPA 1 Uniform Fire Code. National Fire Protection Association (2006)
10. National Fire Protection Association, NFPA 101, Life Safety Code 2000 edition (2000)
11. Bryant S, Preston I (2017) Focus on trends in fires and fire- related fatalities
12. Haynes HJG (2017) Fire loss in the United States during 2016
13. Hall J (2014) The total cost of fire in the United States. Quincy, MA: NFPA
14. Wang Y, Dong YL, Li B, Zhou GC (2013) A fire test on continuous reinforced concrete slabs in a full-scale multi-story steel-framed building. Fire Saf J 61: 232–24210.1016/j.firesaf.2013.08.005 ↗
15. Kirby G, Lapwood BR, Thompson DG (1993) Reinstatement of fire damaged steel and iron framed structures
16. Manes M, Rush D (2017) Meta-analysis of UK, USA and New Zealand fire statistics databases with respect to damage and financial loss. In: Applications of fire engineering: proceedings of the international conference of applications of structural fire engineering (ASFE 2017), pp 179–18810.1201/9781315107202-20 ↗
17. Manes M, Rush D (2017) Meta-analysis of response times and safety systems to the fire size, growth and damage, based on UK, USA and New Zealand fire statistics databases. In: 2nd international conference structures safety under fire blast load. (CONFAB 17). pp 108–117
18. CEN (2009) BS EN 1991-1-2:2002 Eurocode 1- actions on structures; Part 1-2: general actions—actions on structures exposed to fire. Brussels, Belgium
19. Ramachandran G (1988) Probabilistic approach to fire risk evaluation. Fire Technol 24(3): 204–22610.1007/BF01038178 ↗
20. Rush D, Bisby L, Ioannou I, Rossetto T (2014) Towards fragility analysis for concrete buildings in fire: residual capacity of concrete columns. In: 8th SiF. pp 467–474.
21. Bisby L, Gales J, Maluk C (2013) A contemporary review of large-scale non-standard structural fire testing. Fire Sci Rev 2(1): 110.1186/2193-0414-2-1 ↗
22. Borg A, Njå O, Torero JL (2015) A framework for selecting design fires in performance based fire safety engineering. Fire Technol 51(4): 995–101710.1007/s10694-014-0454-x ↗
23. Home Office (2017) Publishing incident recording system data on the fire and rescue service at an incident level: ‘Other building’ fires dataset guidance
24. D’Addario R (1940) Considerazioni sul tasso di premio delle assicurazioni incendi. Bari
25. Ramachandran P, Kirsop G (1969) Preliminary analysis of large fires during 1968. Fire Reserach Note No 763
26. Ramachandran P, Kirsop G (1969) A brief analysis of large fires during 1965 to 1968. Fire Reserach Note No 792
27. Ramachandran G (1970) Fire loss indexes. Fire Reserach Note No 839
28. Rutstein R (1979) The probability of fire in different sectors of industry.pdf. Fire Surv 8(1): 20–23
29. Gaught P, Gallucci J, Smalldridge G (2016) Fire statistics England, 2014/15
30. USFA (2014) National fire incident reporting system
31. International Code Council (2017) Building valuation data
32. US Energy Information Administration. https://www.eia.gov/ . Accessed 11 Sept 2018
33. Commercial Buildings Energy Consumption Survey. https://www.eia.gov/consumption/commercial/ . Accessed 11 Sept 2018
34. Manufacturing Energy Consumption Survey, https://www.eia.gov/consumption/manufacturing/ . Accessed 11 Sept 2018
35. Executive office of the President and Office of Mangement and Budget (2017) North American Industry Classification System. p 963
36. Sandberg M (2004) Statistical determination of ignition frequencies. Master Thesis. p 92
37. Kobayashi Y (2017) Frequency of ignition of non-residential buildings in Japan. Fire Saf J 91: 1035–104310.1016/j.firesaf.2017.03.066 ↗
38. Tillander K, Keski-Rahkonen O (2003) The ignition frequency of structural fires in Finland 1996–1999. Fire Saf Sci. pp 1051–106210.3801/IAFSS.FSS.7-1051 ↗
39. Department for Communities and Local Government (2015) English housing survey, adaptations and accessibility report, 2014–2015
40. Valuation Office Agency (2016) Statistical release non-domestic rating: Stock of properties England and Wales
41. Unite States Census Bureau (2012) Statistical abstract of the United States 2012
42. Holborn PG, Nolan PF, Golt J (2004) An analysis of fire sizes, fire growth rates and times between events using data from fire investigations. Fire Saf J 39(6): 481–52410.1016/j.firesaf.2004.05.002 ↗
43. Bank of England Inflation Calculator. http://bankofengland.education/inflationcalculator/ . Accessed 11 Sept 2018
44. OFX International Money Transfer and Exchange. https://www.ofx.com/en-gb/forex-news/historical-exchange-rates/yearly-average-rates/ . Accessed 11 Sept 2018