Fixed Fire Protection Systems in Tunnels: Issues and Directions
Source abstract
Abstract
Fire protection practices for highway tunnels have been undergoing significant changes in the last decade, largely in response to a number of catastrophic fires that caused tunnel authorities to thoroughly review their fire safety assumptions. One of the fire safety issues currently receiving much attention includes the installation of “active” fire protection systems in addition to the “passive” fire protection features that were until recently considered to be sufficient to mitigate fire risk in tunnels. Passive fire protection measures include the use of fire resistive construction materials which help protect the critical structural elements from damage due to high temperatures. Active fire protection systems include fixed piping systems to deliver water sprays, such as deluge sprinklers and water mist, or other water-based agents such as compressed air or high expansion foam (CAF or Hi-Ex respectively). Active fire protection systems for tunnels are currently referred to as water based fixed fire fighting systems, or FFFS for short. Fire research suggests that measures based solely on passive protection are not likely to be sufficient to protect life and property to the degree warranted by the high monetary and strategic value of modern tunnel infrastructure. Full-scale fire testing and engineering analysis indicate that FFFS have the potential to reduce the impact of a severe fire on the tunnel structure from catastrophic to manageable at an affordable cost. Fire testing with CAF and Hi-Ex foam systems has shown them capable of actually extinguishing very large fires, including hydrocarbon pool fires. Systems based on water sprays on the other hand are not expected to extinguish fires, but rather to control the fire, limit fire growth and heat release rate, prevent fire propagation and provide thermal management. Although there are a few years of experience internationally that have proven sprinkler and deluge sprinkler system to be effective in mitigating tunnel fires, recent testing of FFFS in Europe has concentrated on water mist. One reason is the perception that water mist systems may involve less complex piping and agent storage than CAF or Hi-Ex foam, and may provide equivalent or superior performance with less water and smaller pipes than conventional sprinkler deluge systems. However, many engineering challenges remain to be resolved, such as how much credit to grant to the FFFS in terms of reduced criteria for passive protection, and how exactly to integrate active protection systems with traditional fire safety measures such as the ventilation systems. This article examines some recent developments in understanding how active fire-fighting systems might alter the impact of fires in tunnels.
Source: openaire · Quality: candidate unverified · Source record ↗
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Fire dynamics and safety research · Evacuation and Crowd Dynamics · Fire Detection and Safety Systems
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
References (48)
Show source-provided references
1. World Road Association (PIARC) (1999) Fire and smoke control in road tunnels. PIARC Committee on Road Tunnels (C5)
2. World Road Association (PIARC) (2008) An assessment of fixed fire fighting systems. PIARC Committee on Road Tunnels (C5)
3. NFPA 502 (2004) Standard for road tunnels, bridges, and other limited access highways. Annex D. National Fire Protection Association, Quincy, MA, USA
4. NFPA 502 (2008) Standard for road tunnels, bridges, and other limited access highways, Chapter 10. Annexes B and E. National Fire Protection Association, Quincy, MA, USA
5. Beard AN, Carvel RO (eds) (2005) The handbook of tunnel fire safety, Chapters 1 to 3. Thomas Telford Publishing, London10.1680/hotfs.31685 ↗
6. Haack A (2008) Active and passive fire protection—which way should we go? In: Proceedings, third ISTSS—international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Stockholm, Sweden, 12–14 March, 2008, SP, Sweden
7. Kratzmeir S (2010) Fixed fire fighting systems in tunnels—integration and compensation. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010. SP, Sweden, pp 323–332
8. Jönsson J, Johnson P (2010) Suppression systems—trade-offs & benefits. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010, SP, Sweden, pp 271–282
9. Bendelius A (2004) The latest PIARC road tunnel fire and smoke control publications. In: Routes roads No. 324 (IV—2004), pp 52–63
10. NFPA 502 (2009) Standard for road tunnels, bridges, and other limited access highways. Report on comments meeting agenda, NFPA 502-2011 revision cycle. National Fire Protection Association, Quincy, MA, USA
11. Ingason H (2010) Preface. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010, SP, Sweden, p 3
12. Ingason H, Lönnermark A (2010) A new method of risk assessment when fighting tunnel fires. Article in SP BrandPosten #42/2010. SP Technical Research Institute of Sweden
13. Directive 2004/54/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2004 on minimum safety requirements for tunnels in the trans-European road network, Official Journal of the European Union L 167/39, Brussels, Belgium, 30 April 2004
14. Ingason H (2007) The technical arguments against sprinklers in road tunnels do not stand up. Article in SP BrandPosten #36/2007. SP Technical Research Institute of Sweden
15. Brinson A (2010) Active fire protection in tunnels. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010, SP, Sweden, pp 47–58
16. Ingason H, Lönnermark A (2005) Heat release rates from heavy goods vehicle trailer fires in tunnels. Fire Safety J 40(7):648–66810.1016/j.firesaf.2005.06.002 ↗
17. Brandt A, Wighus R (2005) Real-scale tests of compressed air foam system in Runehamar test tunnel 2005. Sintef NBL as, Trondheim, Norway, October 2006
18. EUREKA Projekt EU 499 FIRETUN (1995) Fire in transport tunnels—report on full scale fire tests. Studiengesellschaft für Stahlanwendung, e.V., Düsseldorf, November 1995
19. Opstad K, Stensaas J, Brandt A (2006) Development of innovative technologies. UPTUN Final Report for work package 2, Task 2–4, September 2006
20. Starke H (2010) Fire suppression in road tunnel fires by a water mist system—results of the SOLIT project. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010, SP, Sweden, pp 311–321
21. Guigas X, Weatherill A (2005) Water mist tests for the A86 east tunnel. International congress safety innovation criteria inside tunnels. Gijón, Spain
22. Mawhinney JR (2005) Approval testing of a Hi-Fog water mist system for protection of a passenger vehicle tunnel, Paris, France. HAI Report 5022-010-1, for Marioff Oy, Finland, October 7, 2005
23. Mawhinney JR, Ingason H (2007) Full-scale fire testing of suppressed heavy goods vehicle fires in road tunnels. HAI Client Report 5022-010-2, for Marioff Oy, Finland, August 2007
24. Palle C (2010) Full scale tunnel fire tests of VID Fire-Kill low pressure water mist tunnel fire protection system in runehamar test tunnel, spring 2009. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Poster presentation in proceedings of the fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and securityk, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, SP, Sweden, pp 586–589
25. Mawhinney JR (2002) A critique of claims of smoke scrubbing by water mist. In: Proceedings of the national fire protection research foundation, fire suppression and detection research application symposium, Tampa, FL, January 23–25, 2002
26. Mawhinney JR (2008) Principles of water mist fire suppression systems. In: Cote AE et al (eds) Section 16, chapter 8 in NFPA fire protection handbook, 20th edn. National Fire Protection Association, One Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA
27. Arvidson M (2010) Large scale water spray and water mist fire suppression system tests. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010, SP, Sweden, pp 283–292
28. Ingason H (2005) Fire dynamics in tunnels, Chap. 11. In: Beard AN, Carvel RO (eds), The handbook of tunnel fire safety. Thomas Telford Publishing, London, pp 231–26310.1680/hotfs.31685.0011 ↗
29. Mawhinney JR, DiNenno PJ, Williams FW (1999) Using water mist for flashover suppression on navy ships. HOTWC 1999, Halon technical options working conference, Albuquerque, NM, April 27–29, 1999
30. Mawhinney JR, Dlugogorski BZ, Kim AK (1994) A closer look at the extinguishing properties of water mist. In: Invited lecture in proceedings: International Association for Fire Safety Science (IAFSS) conference, Ottawa, ON, June 13–17, 199410.3801/IAFSS.FSS.4-47 ↗
31. Mawhinney JR, Trelles J (2008) The use of CFD-FDS modeling for establishing performance criteria for water mist systems in very large fires in tunnels. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings of the third international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Stockholm, Sweden, SP Report 2008:11, March 12–14, 2008, pp 29–42
32. Ingason H, Lönnermark A (2010) Effects of longitudinal ventilation on fire growth and maximum heat release rate. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, March 17–19, 2010, SP, Sweden, pp 395–406
33. Kratzmeir S (2010) Fixed fire fighting systems in tunnels—integration and compensation. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010, SP, Sweden, pp 325–326
34. Carvel R (2008) Design fires for tunnel water mist suppression systems. In: Proceedings, Third International Symposium on Tunnel Safety and Security (ISTSS), Stockholm, Sweden, 12–14 March, 2008, SP Fire Technology
35. Lacroix D (2001) To what extent should road tunnel structures resist fire? The French Approach. 3rd International conference on tunnel fires, Washington, DC, USA, October 9–11, 2001
36. Cheong MK, Spearpoint MJ, Fleischmann CM (2009) Calibrating an FDS simulation of goods vehicle fire growth in a tunnel using the Runehamar experiment. J Fire Protect Eng 19:177–19610.1177/1042391508101981 ↗
37. Trelles J, Mawhinney JR (2010) CFD investigation of large scale pallet stack fires in tunnel protected by water mist systems. J Fire Protect Eng 20(3):149–19910.1177/1042391510367359 ↗
38. Mawhinney JR, Trelles J (2010) Performance testing of fire protection systems in tunnels: integrating test data with CFD simulations. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010, SP, Sweden, pp 297–309
39. Noordjik LM et al (2010) Emerging problems for immersed tunnels. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010, SP, Sweden, pp 211–222
40. Clement F (2010) Fire protection of concrete structures exposed to fast fires. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010, SP, Sweden, pp 223–234
41. Pimienta P et al (CSTB) Fire protection options for concrete tunnel linings. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010, SP, Sweden, pp 235–248
42. Kim HK, Lönnermark A et al (2010) Effective firefighting operations in road tunnels. SP Report 2010:10. SP Technical Research Institute of Sweden, Borås, Sweden, pp 1–89
43. Jayaweera TM, Yu H-Z (2008) Scaling water mist fire suppression under low drop Reynolds number conditions. Fire Safety J 43(1):63–7010.1016/j.firesaf.2007.01.004 ↗
44. Yu H-Z, Zhou X, Ditch B (2008) Experimental validation of froude-modeling-based physical scaling of water mist cooling of enclosure fires. In: Proceedings of 9th international symposium on fire safety science, pp 553–564
45. Colella F, Rein G, Verda V, Borchiellini R, Carvel R, Steinhaus T, Torero JL (2010) Design of tunnel ventilations systems for fire emergencies using multiscale modelling. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Proceedings, fourth international symposium on tunnel safety and security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010, SP, Sweden, pp 427–438
46. Floyd J (2010) Coupling a network HVAC model to a computational fluid dynamics model using large eddy simulation. Interflam 2010: Proceedings of the twelfth international conference, University of Nottingham, United Kingdom
47. Almand K, Gottuk D, Mawhinney J (2008) International road tunnel fire detection research project—Phase II Task 5 and 6: monitoring and fire demonstration in the Lincoln Tunnel. National Fire Protection Research Foundation, Report 200803143, Quincy, MA
48. Rogner A (2010) Safety and reliability of fire detection systems in road tunnels. In: Lönnermark A, Ingason H (eds) Poster presentation in Proceedings, Fourth International Symposium on Tunnel Safety and Security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, 17–19 March, 2010, SP, Sweden, pp 561–564