An Evaluation of Woody Biomass and Pulpwood Market Competition within a Range of Procurement Distances
Source abstract
Abstract
Abstract In the Southern United States, a rising number of biomass facilities have created new market opportunities for forest landowners, consulting foresters, and loggers, which could increase the competition between the biomass market and pulpwood market for forest biomass. Thus, comparing the profits from conventional roundwood harvesting and biomass harvesting within a range of procurement distances could be crucial to make a harvest decision. In this study, we considered two harvesting systems: conventional and biomass. We developed a decision support tool to predict and compare the final stumpage value from both harvesting systems based on the stand and site conditions, market conditions, and distance to the nearest market. We grew (simulated) loblolly pine (Pinus taeda) plantations to six different thinning ages (12, 14, 16, 18, 20, and 22 yr) at five different site indices (17, 20, 23, 26, and 29 m at a base age of 25 yr) using the PTAEDA4.0 software. Different models were fitted and evaluated for certain training and validating criteria. In both harvesting systems, we select the cube root-transformed model as the best model. Using the models, we predict that the utilization of logging residues and pulpwood as wood chips may yield a higher return to the landowner when the delivered price of the wood chips is comparable to the delivered price of the pulpwood and within the same procurement distance. The selected models thus serve as a decision support tool to inform stakeholders to further maximize their economic return from timber harvesting operations by selecting the most profitable option.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Forest Management and Policy · Forest Biomass Utilization and Management · Bioenergy crop production and management
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
References (91)
Show source-provided references
1. Anderson N. and Mitchell.D. 2016. Forest operations and woody biomass logistics to improve efficiency, value, and sustainability. Bioenergy Res. 9(2): 518– 533. DO:10.1007/s12155-016-9735-1
2. Anderson, Hayes L., Keyser P. D. Lituma C. M. Sutter R. D. and Zollner.D. 2016. Shortleaf pine restoration plan: Restoring an American forest legacy. Shortleaf Pine Initiative, Knoxville, TN.
3. Barrett S. M., Bolding M. C. and Munsell.J. F. 2017. Characteristics of logging businesses across Virginia's diverse physiographic regions. Forests8(12). DOI:10.3390/f8120468
4. Belyakov N. 2019. Sustainable Power Generation: Current Status, Future Challenges, and Perspectives. Academic Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
5. Benjamin J., Lilieholm R. J. and Damery.D. 2009. Challenges and opportunities for the northeastern forest bioindustry. J. Forestry107(3): 125– 131. DOI:10.1093/jof/107.3.125
6. Bolding M. C. 2002. Forest fuel reduction and energywood production using a CTL/smaller chipper harvesting system. Master's thesis.Auburn University, Auburn, Alabama.
7. Bolding M. C. and Lanford.B. L. 2001. Forest fuel reduction through energy wood production using a small chipper/CTL harvesting system. In:Appalachian Hardwoods; Managing Change. Proceedings of the 24th Annual Council on Forest Engineering Meeting;WangJ.WolfordM. and McNeelJ. (Eds.); July 15–19, 2001; Snowshoe, West Virginia. Council on Forest Engineering 65-7, Corvallis, Oregon.
8. Bowyer J. L. 2008. The green movement and the forest products industry. Forest Prod. J. 58(7): 6.
9. Brandeis C. and Abt.K. L. 2019. Roundwood use by southern wood pellet mills: Findings from timber product output mill surveys. J. Forestry117(5): 427– 434. DOI:10.1093/jofore/fvz042
10. Brown M., Nebeker T. and Honea.C. 1987. Thinning increases loblolly pine vigor and resistance to bark beetles. South. J. Appl. Forestry11: 28– 31.
11. Burkhart H. E., Amateis R. L. Westfall J. A. and Daniels.R. F. 2008. PTAEDA4.0: Simulation of individual tree growth, stand development and economic evaluation in loblolly pine plantations. User Manual, 27. Department of Forestry, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, Virginia. https://fmrc.frec.vt.edu/content/dam/fmrc_frec_vt_edu/documents/ptaeda4.0%20manual.pdf. Accessed October 20, 2021.
12. Burton J. D. 1982. Sawtimber by prescription—The sudden sawlog story through age 33. Research Paper SO-179. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Southern Forest Experiment Station, New Orleans, Louisiana.
13. Butler B. J., Hewes J. H. Dickinson B. J. Andrejczyk K. Markowski-Lindsay M. and Butler.S. 2016. Family forest ownerships of the United States, 2013: Tabular results from the USDA forest service, national woodland owner survey.Dept. Agric., Forest Serv., North. Res. Stn. 114(November):638–647.
14. Census Bureau. 2015. USA Trade. US Department of Commerce, Washington, D.C.
15. Conrad J. L. 2018. Costs and challenges of log truck transportation in Georgia, USA. Forests9(10). DOI:10.3390/f9100650
16. Conrad J. L., and Bolding.M. C. 2011. Virginia's woody biomass market: Opportunities and implications. South. J. Appl. Forestry35(2): 67– 72. DOI:10.1093/sjaf/35.2.67
17. Conrad J. L., Bolding M. C. Aust W. M. Smith R. L. and Horcher.A. 2013. Harvesting productivity and costs when utilizing energywood from pine plantations of the southern Coastal Plain USA. Biomass and Bioenergy52: 85– 95. DOI:10.1016/j.biombioe.2013.02.038
18. Conrad J. L., Bolding M. C. Smith R. L. and Aust.W. M. 2011. Wood-energy market impact on competition, procurement practices, and profitability of landowners and forest products industry in the U.S. south. Biomass and Bioenergy35(1): 280– 287. DOI:10.1016/j.biombioe.2010.08.038
19. Conrad J. L., Greene W. D. and Hiesl.P. 2018. The evolution of logging businesses in Georgia 1987–2017 and South Carolina 2012–2017. Forest Sci. 64(6): 671– 681.
20. Dean T. and Baldwin.V. C. J. 1993. Using a density-management diagram to develop thinning schedules for loblolly pine plantations. Research Paper SO-275. New Orleans, LA: US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Southern Forest Experiment Station, New Orleans, Louisiana.
21. Eisenbies M. H., Vance E. D. Aust W. M. and Seiler.J. R. 2009. Intensive utilization of harvest residues in southern pine plantations: Quantities available and implications for nutrient budgets and sustainable site productivity. Bioenergy Res. 2(3): 90– 98. DOI:10.1007/s12155-009-9036-z
22. Evans A. M. 2008. Synthesis of Knowledge from Woody Biomass Removal Case Studies 36. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Forest Guild, Santa Fe, New Mexico. https://www.firescience.gov/projects/07-3-2-02/project/07-3-2-02_07_3_2_02_biomass_case_studies_report.pdf. Accessed October 20, 2021.
23. Fettig C. J., Klepzig K. D. Billings R. F. Munson A. S. Nebeker T. E. Negrón J. F. and Nowak.J. 2007. The effectiveness of vegetation management practices for prevention and control of bark beetle infestations in coniferous forests of the western and southern United States. Forest Ecol. Manag. 238(1–3): 24– 53. DOI:10.1016/j.foreco.2006.10.011
24. Fox T. R., Jokela E. J. and Allen.H. L. 2004. Pine plantation silviculture. General Technical Report SRS–75. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Southern Research Station, Asheville, North Carolina. pp.63– 82.
25. Galik C. S., Abt R. and Wu.Y. 2009. Forest biomass supply in the southeastern United States—Implications for industrial roundwood and bioenergy production. J. Forestry107(2): 69– 77.
26. Gan J. and Mayfield.C. 2007. Forest bioenergy production and rural economic development. In:Sustainable Forestry for Bioenergy and Bio-Based Products: Trainer's Curriculum Notebook. HubbardW.BilesL.MayfieldC. and AshtonS.(Eds.).Southern Forest Research Partnership, Inc., Athens, Georgia. pp.217– 220.
27. Gold R. 2009. Wood pellets catch fire as renewable energy source.The Wall Street J. July 7, 2009.https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB124691728110402383. Accessed October 20, 2021.
28. Grove P. M., Conrad J. L. Harris T. G. and Dahlen.J. 2020. Consulting forester timber sale practices in the US south. Forest Sci. 66(2): 221– 229. DOI:10.1093/forsci/fxz068
29. Guldin J. M. 2019. Restoration of native fire-adapted southern pine-dominated forest ecosystems: Diversifying the tools in the silvicultural toolbox. Forest Sci. 65(4): 508– 518. DOI:10.1093/forsci/fxz005
30. Han H.-S., Lee H. W. and Johnson.L. R. 2004. Economic feasibility of an integrated harvesting system for small-diameter trees in southwest Idaho. Forest Prod. J. 54(2): 21– 27.
31. Harrill H. and Han.H.-S. 2012. Productivity and cost of integrated harvesting of wood chips and sawlogs in stand conversion operations. Int. J. Forestry Res. 2012: 1– 10. DOI:10.1155/2012/893079
32. Hartley D. S., Thompson D. N. and Cai.H. 2021. Woody feedstock 2020 state of technology report. US Department of Energy, Office of Scientific and Technical Information.DOI:10.2172/1782211
33. Haywood J. D. 2005. Influence of precommercial thinning and fertilization on total stem volume and lower stem form of loblolly pine. South. J. Appl. Forestry29(4): 215– 220. DOI:10.1093/sjaf/29.4.215
34. Hernández G. A., Harper R. A. and South.D. B. 2016. Tree planting in the South, 1925 to 2012. Tree Planter's Notes59: 4– 8.
35. Hillring B. 2006. World trade in forest products and wood fuel. Biomass and Bioenergy30(10): 815– 825. DOI:10.1016/j.biombioe.2006.04.002
36. International Energy Agency (IEA). 2020. World Energy Balances 2020 (database). https://www.iea.org/reports/sustainable-bioenergy-for-georgia-a-roadmap. Accessed September 20, 2021.
37. Jernigan P., Gallagher T. Aulakh J. Tufts R. and McDonald.T. 2013. Implementing residue chippers on harvesting operations in the southeastern US for biomass recovery. Int. J. Forest Eng. 24: 129– 136.
38. Johnson T., Bentley J. and Howell.M. 2008. The South's timber industry—An assessment of timber product output and use, 2005. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service Resource Bulletin SRS-135. U.S. Department of Agriculture Forest Service, Southern Research Station,Asheville, North Carolina.
39. Joudrey J., McDow W. Smith T. and Larson.B. 2012. European Power from U.S. Forests: How Evolving EU Policy is Shaping the Transatlantic Trade in Wood Biomass. Environmental Defense Fund, New York, New York.
40. Kizha A., Han H.-S. Montgomery T. and Hohl.A. 2015. Biomass power plant feedstock procurement: Modeling transportation cost zones and the potential for competition. Calif. Agric. J. 69(3): 184– 190.
41. Kohavi R. 1995. A study of cross-validation and bootstrap for accuracy estimation and model selection. Proceedings of the Fourteenth International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence; August 20–25, 1995; Montreal, Quebec, Canada.https://www.ijcai.org/Proceedings/95-2/Papers/016.pdf. Accessed October 20, 2021.
42. Koirala A., Kizha A. R. and Baral.S. 2017. Modeling height-diameter relationship and volume of Teak (Tectona grandis L. F.) in central lowlands of Nepal. J. Trop. Forestry Environ. 7(1): 28– 42. DOI:10.31357/jtfe.v7i1.3020
43. Kumarappan S., Joshi S. and MacLean.H. L. 2009. Biomass supply for biofuel production: Estimates for the United States and Canada. BioResources4(3): 1070– 1087. DOI:10.15376/biores.4.3.1070-1087
44. Kwak S. G. and Kim.J. H. 2017. Central limit theorem: The cornerstone of modern statistics. Korean J. Anesthesiol. 70(2): 144– 156.
45. Leinonen A. 2004. Harvesting technology of forest residues for fuel in the USA and Finland. VTT Tiedotteita - Valtion Teknillinen Tutkimuskeskus2229: 3– 132.
46. Liski E., Jounela P. Korpunen H. Sosa A. Lindroos O. and Jylhä.P. 2020. Modeling the productivity of mechanized CTL harvesting with statistical machine learning methods. Int. J. Forest Eng. 31(3) :253–262.DOI:10.1080/14942119.2020.1820750
47. Louisiana: Public Law Louisiana Act 84. 2020. https://www.legis.la.gov/legis/BillInfo.aspx?s=20rs&b=HB442. Accessed September 20,2021.
48. McDonald T. P., Taylor S. E. Rummer R. B. and Valenzuela.J. 2001. Information needs for increasing log transport efficiency. First International Precision Forestry Symposium, 12 pp.https://www.srs.fs.usda.gov/pubs/ja/ja_mcdonald012.pdf. Accessed October 20, 2021.
49. Mcgregor K. F., Watt M. S. Hulme P. E. and Duncan.R. P. 2012. What determines pine naturalization: Species traits, climate suitability or forestry use?Divers. Distrib. 18(10): 1013– 1023. DOI:10.1111/j.1472-4642.2012.00942.x
50. McKeand S., Mullin T. Byram T. and White.T. 2003. Deployment of genetically improved loblolly and slash pines in the south. J. Forestry101(3): 32– 37. DOI:10.1093/jof/101.3.32
51. Moskalik T. and Gendek.A. 2019. Production of chips from logging residues and their quality for energy: A review of European literature. Forests10(3): 262. DOI:10.3390/f10030262
52. Nebeker T. E., Hodges D. J. Karr K. B. and Moehring.M. D. 1985. Thinning practices in southern pines—With pest management recommendations. Technical Bulletin 1703. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service. https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwj-1-qD_tnzAhVjmWoFHSuBAwEQFnoECAQQAQ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fageconsearch.umn.edu%2Frecord%2F156818%2Ffiles%2Ftb1703.pdf&usg=AOvVaw2kFEqH7ZT-aaQIPuHnCdO5. Accessed October 20, 2021.
53. Nesbit T. S., Alavalapati J. R. R. Dwivedi P. and Marinescu.M. V. 2011. Economics of ethanol production using feedstock from slash pine (Pinus elliotti) plantations in the southern United States. South. J. Appl. Forestry35(2): 61– 66.
54. Nickens E. T. 2014. Why U.S. forests are fueling Europe.Audubon, Nat. Audubon Soc. September–October 2014.https://www.audubon.org/magazine/september-october-2014/why-us-forests-are-fueling-europe. Accessed October 20, 2021.
55. North Carolina: Public Law North Carolina Session Law 2012-78. 2012. https://www.ncleg.gov/EnactedLegislation/SessionLaws/PDF/2011-2012/SL2012-78.pdf. Accessed September 20,2021.
56. Nowak J. 2004. Southern pine beetle prevention and restoration. Forest Landowners Conf. Proc. 63: 21– 22.
57. Nowak J., Asaro C. Klepzig K. and Billings.R. 2008. The southern pine beetle prevention initiative: Working for healthier forests. J. Forestry106(5): 261– 267. DOI:10.1093/jof/106.5.261
58. Nowak J., Meeker J. R. Coyle D. R. Steiner C. A. and Brownie.C. 2015. Southern pine beetle infestations in relation to forest stand conditions, previous thinning, and prescribed burning: Evaluation of the southern pine beetle prevention program. J. Forestry113(5): 454– 462. DOI:10.5849/jof.15-002
59. Pan F., Han H.-S. Johnson L. R. and Elliot.W. J. 2007. Production and cost of harvesting and transporting small-diameter trees for energy. International Mountain Logging and 13th Pacific Northwest Skyline Symposium,SessionsJ. and HavillY.(Eds.),April 1–6, 2007, Corvallis, Oregon. Sponsored by Department of Forest Engineering, Oregon State University, and International Union of Forest Research Organizations. pp. 215–225.https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwiw6cHWn9rzAhXMnGoFHaB-D6wQFnoECAIQAQ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.iufro.org%2Fdownload%2Ffile%2F4702%2F4504%2F30000-mountain-logging-symp07_p_pdf%2F&usg=AOvVaw0WhYnMj7lyiTfn8mmdIAVO. Accessed October 20, 2021.
60. Peksa M., Dolzan P. Grassi A. Heinimo J. Junginger M. Ranta T. and Walter.A. 2007. Global wood pellets markets and industry: Policy drivers, market status and raw material potential. IEA Bioenergy Task40: 5, 120.
61. Perlack R. D., Wright L. L. Turhollow A. F. Graham R. L. Stokes B. J. and Erbach.D. C. 2005. Biomass as Feedstock for a Bioenergy and Bioproducts Industry: The Technical Feasibility of a Billion-Ton Annual Supply. Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee.
62. Pokharel R., Grala R. K. Grebner D. L. and Cooke.W. H. 2019. Mill willingness to use logging residues to produce electricity: A spatial logistic regression approach. Forest Sci. 65(3): 277– 288. DOI:10.1093/forsci/fxy061
63. Prestemon J., Pye J. Barbour J. Smith G. R. Ince P. Steppleton C. and Xu.W. 2010. U.S. wood-using mill locations - 2005. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Southern Research Station, Asheville, North Carolina. https://www.srs.fs.usda.gov/econ/data/mills/. Accessed October 20, 2021.
64. Primary Forest Products Network. https://primary.forestproductslocator.org/. Accessed September 1, 2021.
65. R Core Team. 2019. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. https://www.R-project.org/. Accessed October 20, 2020.
66. Rankin W. and Herbert.N. 2014. Restoration in the southern Appalachians: A dialogue among scientists, planners, and land managers. General Technical Report SRS-GTR-189. US Department of Agriculture-Forest Service, Southern Research Station,Asheville, North Carolina. pp.1– 48.
67. Richardson J. 2006. Sustainable production systems for bioenergy: Impacts on forest resources and utilization of wood for energy. Biomass and Bioenergy30: 279– 384.
68. Schultz R. P. 1997. Loblolly pine: The Ecology and Culture of the Loblolly Pine (Pinus taeda L.). Agriculture Handbook 713. US Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C.
69. Schultz R. P. 1999. Loblolly—The pine for the twenty-first century. New Forests17(1–3): 71– 88.
70. Shabani N., Akhtari S. and Sowlati.T. 2013. Value chain optimization of forest biomass for bioenergy production: A review. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 23: 299– 311. DOI:10.1016/j.rser.2013.03.005
71. Smidt M. F., Zhang Y. and Zheng.B. 2012. Financial assessment of logging residue collection in the southeast United States. Forest Prod. J. 62: 10– 17.
72. Smith B. W., Miles P. D. Vissage J. S. and Pugh.S. A. 2004. Forest resources of the United States, 2002. General Technical Report NC-241. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, North Central Forest Experiment Station, St. Paul, Minnesota. DOI:10.2737/NC-GTR-241
73. Smith B. W., Vissage J. S. Darr D. R. and Sheffield.R. M. 2001. Forest resources of the United States, 1997. General Technical Report NS-219. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, North Carolina Central Research Station,Asheville, North Carolina.
74. South Carolina Code of Laws. 2021. Title 56 Chapter 5. https://www.scstatehouse.gov/code/t56c005.php. Accessed September 20, 2021.
75. South D. B. and Harper.R. A. 2016. A decline in timberland continues for several southern yellow pines. Forest Ecol. 114(March): 116– 124.
76. Spelter H. and Toth.D. 2009. North America's wood pellet sector. Research Paper FPL-RP-656. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory, Madison, Wisconsin.
77. Stephens S. L., Collins B. M. Fettig C. J. Finney M. A. Hoffman C. M. Knapp E. E. North M. P. Safford H. and Wayman.R. B. 2018. Drought, tree mortality, and wildfire in forests adapted to frequent fire. BioScience68(2): 77– 88. DOI:10.1093/biosci/bix146
78. Stokes B. J. 1998. Harvesting systems for multiple products—An update for the United States.In: IEA Bioenergy Wood Fuels from Conventional Forestry; Proceedings of the Third Annual Workshop of Activity 1.2 (Harvesting) / Task XII / IEA Bioenergy;HakkilaP.HeinoM. and PuranenE. (Eds.); October 18, 1997; Jasper, Alberta, Canada. The Finnish Forest Research Institute, Helsinki, Finland. pp. 49–56.https://www.srs.fs.usda.gov/pubs/ja/ja_stokes012.pdf. Accessed Oct 20, 2021.
79. Stokes, Watson W. F. and Sirois.D. L.1987. Factors affecting power requirements for chipping whole trees. ASAE Paper 87-6012. American Society of Agricultural Engineers, St. Joseph, Michigan.
80. Susaeta A., Alavalapati J. Lal P. Matta J. R. and Merce.E. 2010. Assessing public preferences for forest biomass based energy in the southern United States. Environ. Manag. 45(4): 697– 710. DOI:10.1007/s00267-010-9445-y
81. TimberMart-South. 2010. Norris Foundation, Athens, Georgia: 1st quarter. http://www.timbermart-south.com/. Accessed May 12, 2020.
82. TimberMart-South. 2020. Norris Foundation, Athens, Georgia: 1st quarter. http://www.timbermart-south.com/. Accessed May 12, 2020.
83. Virginia: Public Law Virginia House Bill 2072. 2015. https://lis.virginia.gov/cgi-bin/legp604.exe?151+sum+HB2072. Accessed September 20,2021.
84. Voegele E. 2021. USDA: US wood pellet exports at 556,802 metric tons in February. Biomass Mag.http://biomassmagazine.com/articles/17860/usda-us-wood-pellet-exports-at-556-802-metric-tons-in-february. Accessed October 20, 2021.
85. Vogt K. A., Andreu M. G. Vogt D. J. and Sigurdardottir.R. 2005. Societal values and economic return added for forest owners by linking forests to bioenergy production. J. Forestry103: 21– 27.
86. Wakeley P. C. 1954. Planting the Southern Pines. US Department of Agriculture, Agriculture Monograph No. 18,Washington, D.C.
87. Waldron J. D. 2011. Forest restoration following southern pine beetle. In:Southern Pine Beetle II. General Technical Report SRS-140. CoulsonR. N. and KlepzigK. D.(Eds.).US Department of Agriculture Forest Service, Southern Research Station, Asheville, North Carolina.pp.353– 363, 140, 353– 363.
88. Wear D. N. and Greis.J. G. 2012. The southern forest futures project: Summary report. General Technical Report SRS-GTR-168. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Southern Research Station, Asheville, North Carolina.
89. Westbrook M. D., Greene W. D. and Izlar.R. L. 2007. Utilizing forest biomass by adding a small chipper to a tree-length southern pine harvesting operation. South. J. Appl. Forestry31(4): 165– 169. DOI:10.1093/sjaf/31.4.165
90. Withycombe R. P. 1982. Estimating costs of collecting and transporting forest residues in the northern Rocky Mountain Region. General Technical Report INT-81. US Department of Agriculture,ServiceForestIntermountainForestand RangeOgden,Utah.
91. Xi W., Waldron J. D. Cairns D. M. Lafon C. W. Birt A. G. Tchakerian M. D. Klepzig K. D. and Coulson.R. N. 2012. Restoration of southern pine forests after the southern pine beetle. In:A Goal-Oriented Approach to Forest Landscape Restoration. Springer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.pp.321– 354. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-5338-9_12. Accessed October 20, 2021.