A Productivity and Cost Comparison of Two Systems for Producing Biomass Fuel from Roadside Forest Treatment Residues
Source abstract
Abstract
Abstract Forest operations generate large quantities of forest biomass residues that can be used for production of bioenergy and bioproducts. However, a significant portion of recoverable residues are inaccessible to large chip vans, making use financially infeasible. New production systems must be developed to increase productivity and reduce costs to facilitate use of these materials. We present a comparison of two alternative systems to produce biomass fuel (i.e., “hog fuel”) from forest residues that are inaccessible to chip vans: (1) forwarding residues in fifth-wheel end-dump trailers to a concentration yard, where they can be stored and then ground directly into chip vans, and (2) grinding residues on the treatment unit and forwarding the hog fuel in high-sided dump trucks to a concentration yard, where it can be stored and then reloaded into chip vans using a front-end loader. To quantify the productivity and costs of these systems, work study data were collected for both systems on the same treatment unit in northern Idaho in July 2009. With standard machine rate calculations, the observed costs from roadside to loaded chip van were $23.62 per bone dry ton (BDT) for slash forwarding and $24.52 BDT−1 for in-woods grinding. Results indicate that for harvest units with conditions similar to the test area, slash forwarding is most appropriate for sites with dispersed residues and long-distance in-woods grinder mobilization. For sites with densely piled roadside residues, in-wood grinding is likely to be a more productive and less costly option for residue recovery.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Forest Biomass Utilization and Management · Bioenergy crop production and management · Environmental Impact and Sustainability
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
References (23)
Show source-provided references
1. Baker, S., Westbrook, M. Jr., and W. Greene. 2010 . Evaluation of integrated harvesting systems in pine stands of the southern United States . Biomass Bioenergy34 :720 –727 .
2. Bolding, C. and B. Lanford. 2005 . Wildfire fuel harvesting and resultant biomass utilization using a cut-to-length/small chipper system . Forest Prod. J . 55(12) :181 –189 .
3. Bolding, M., L. Kellogg, and C. Davis. 2009 . Productivity and costs of an integrated mechanical forest fuel reduction operation in southwest Oregon . Forest Prod. J . 59(3) :35 –46 .
4. Briggs, D. 1994 . Forest products measurements and conversion factors with special emphasis on the U.S. Pacific Northwest . College of Forest Resources, University of Washington , Seattle .
5. Brinker, R., J. Kinard, B. Rummer, and B. Lanford. 2002 . Machine rates for selected forest harvesting machines. Circular 296 (revised) . Alabama Agricultural Experiment Station , Auburn University, Auburn .
6. Bureau of Labor Statistics . 2009 . Occupational employment statistics: May 2009 state occupational employment and wage estimates, Idaho . US Department of Labor , Washington, D.C .
7. Demchik, M., D. Abbas, D. Current, D. Arnosti, M. Theimer, and P. Johnson. 2009 . Combining biomass harvest and forest fuel reduction in the Superior National Forest, Minnesota . J. Forestry107(5) :235 –241 .
8. Desrochers, L., G. Puttock, and M. Ryans. 1993 . The economics of chipping logging residues at roadside: A study of three systems . Biomass Bioenergy5(6) :401 –411 .
9. Gan, J. and C. Smith. 2007 . Co-benefits of utilizing logging residues for bioenergy production: The case for East Texas, USA . Biomass Bioenergy31(9) :623 –630 .
10. Han, H.-S., J. Halbrook, F. Pan, and L. Salazar. 2010 . Economic evaluation of a roll-off trucking system removing forest biomass resulting from shaded fuelbreak treatments . Biomass Bioenergy24 :1006 –1016 .
11. Han, H.-S., H. Lee, and L. Johnson. 2004 . Economic feasibility of an integrated harvesting system for small-diameter trees in southwest Idaho . Forest Prod. J . 54(2) :21 –27 .
12. Harrill, H. and H.-S. Han. 2010 . Application of hook-lift trucks in centralized logging slash grinding operations . Biofuels1(3) :399 –408 .
13. Harrill, H., H.-S. Han, and F. Pan. 2009 . Combining slash bundling with in-woods grinding operations . In:Proceedings of the Council on Forest Engineering Annual Meeting , June 15–18, 2009 , Kings Beach, California .
14. Jones, G., D. Loeffler, D. Calkin, and W. Chung. 2010 . Forest treatment residues for thermal energy compared with disposal by onsite burning: Emissions and energy return . Biomass Bioenergy34 :737 –746 .
15. Mitchell, D. and T. Gallagher. 2007 . Chipping whole trees for fuel chips: A production study. South . J. Appl. Forestry31(4) :176 –180 .
16. Miyata, E. 1980 . Determining fixed and operating costs of logging equipment. General Technical Report NC-55 . USDA Forest Service , North Central Forest Experiment Station, St. Paul, Minnesota .
17. Olsen, E., M. Hossain, and M. Miller. 1998 . Statistical comparison of methods used in harvesting work studies. Research Contribution 23 . Forest Research Laboratory , College of Forestry, Oregon State University, Corvallis .
18. Pan, F., H.-S. Han, and W. Elliot. 2010 . Production and cost of harvesting, processing, and transporting small-diameter (≤ 5 inches) trees for energy . Forest Prod. J . 58(5) :47 –53 .
19. Rawlings, C., B. Rummer, C. Seeley, C. Thomas, D. Morrison, H.-S. Han, L. Cheff, D. Atkins, D. Graham, and K. Windell. 2004 . A study of how to decrease the costs of collecting processing and transporting slash . Montana Community Development Corporation , Missoula .
20. SAS Institute Inc . 2004 . Base SAS 9.1 Procedures Guide . SAS Institute Inc ., Cary, North Carolina .
21. Simpson, W. T. 1999 . Drying and control of moisture content and dimensional changes, chap. 12 , pp . 12.1 –12.20 . In:Wood Handbook—Wood as an Engineering Material . General Technical Report FPL-GTR-113 . USDA Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory , Madison, Wisconsin .
22. Smith, W., P. Miles, C. Perry, and S. Pugh. 2009 . Forest Resources of the United States, 2007. General Technical Report . USDA Forest Service , Department of Agriculture , Forest Service, Washington, D.C . 336 pp .
23. US Department of Energy . 2011 . U.S. billion-ton update: Biomass supply for a bioenergy and bioproducts industry . R. D. Perlack and B. J. Stokes (Leads). ORNL/TM-2011/224 . Oak Ridge National Laboratory , Oak Ridge, Tennessee . 227 pp .