journal article·2026-04Open access

Multi-response optimization of drilling temperature and delamination in CNT-enhanced E-glass/epoxy laminates

Sakine Kiratli, Hüseyin Gökce

Applied Physics A· Volume 132· Issue 4

Abstract

Abstract In this study, multi-criteria optimization strategy is proposed to mitigate drilling-induced thermal loading and delamination damage in carbon nanotube (CNT) reinforced E-glass/epoxy laminated composites. The experiments were designed using an L25 orthogonal array, where composite material type (CM), drill geometry (D), cutting speed (Vc), and feed rate (f) were selected as control factors at five levels. Drill-point temperature (T) was monitored using an infrared thermal camera, while the delamination factor ( DF ) was quantified through two-dimensional area analysis of digital microscope images. Optimal parameters for each quality response were initially identified using the Taguchi approach, and a combined performance evaluation of T and DF was carried out via Gray Relational Analysis (GRA) to determine the overall best parameter setting. The influence of each factor was further assessed by ANOVA, revealing that CM and D were the dominant contributors to T, whereas D and f predominantly affected DF . Additionally, response surface-based mathematical models demonstrated high prediction accuracy for both responses (R² > 97%), and their reliability was confirmed through validation trials. SEM examinations provided microstructural insights into surface integrity and damage mechanisms, supporting the statistical findings. Overall, the results establish an effective parameter-selection and multi-objective optimization framework for improved damage control during the drilling of CNT-enhanced laminated composites.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Advanced machining processes and optimization · Mechanical Behavior of Composites · Advanced ceramic materials synthesis

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

References (76)

Show source-provided references
1. G.G. Mahesh, J. Kandasamy, Experimental investigations on the drilling parameters to minimize delamination and taperness of hybrid GFRP/Al2O3 composites by using ANOVA approach. World J. Eng. 20(2), 376–386 (2023)10.1108/WJE-07-2021-0421 ↗
2. A. Sharma, S. Modi, M. Bhatla, A. Goyal, (2021). Study on machining performance of polymer-based composites by drilling process. Materials Today: Proceedings, 47, 2878–288210.1016/j.matpr.2021.04.046 ↗
3. Y.K. Mishra, S. Mishra, A Comprehensive Review on Nd: YAG and CO₂ Laser Drilling of Fiber-Reinforced Composites: Mechanisms, Defects, and Optimization (Engineering Research Ex, 2025)10.1088/2631-8695/addb9a ↗
4. G. Franz, P. Vantomme, M.H. Hassan, A review on drilling of multilayer fiber-reinforced polymer composites and aluminum stacks: optimization of strategies for improving the drilling performance of aerospace assemblies. Fibers. 10(9), 78 (2022)10.3390/fib10090078 ↗
5. D. Sharath, K.N. Mohandas, S. Babu, Characterization of drilling damage in glass laminate composites using lock-in thermography nondestructive evaluation method: a feasibility study. Australian J. Mech. Eng. 22(3), 615–624 (2024)10.1080/14484846.2022.2133677 ↗
6. H. Pallapothu, A. Kumar, (2021). Micro drilling of glass fibre reinforced polymer composites. Materials Today: Proceedings, 46:9252–925610.1016/j.matpr.2020.01.545 ↗
7. D.D.V.S. Chin, bin M.N. Yahya, C. Din, N, (2023). Microperforated Panel Made by Biodegradable Natural Fiber Composite for Acoustic Application. Structural Integrity and Monitoring for Composite Materials (61–71). Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore10.1007/978-981-19-6282-0_4 ↗
8. M. Sen, O. Eryilmaz, B. Bakir, Micro drilling characterization of the carbon and carbon–aramid (hybrid) composites. Polym. Compos. 45(6), 5449–5459 (2024)10.1002/pc.28138 ↗
9. K. Biruk-Urban, P. Bere, J. Józwik, Machine learning models in drilling of different types of glass-fiber-reinforced polymer composites. Polymers. 15(23), 4609 (2023)10.3390/polym15234609 ↗
10. N. Geier, K. Patra, R.S. Anand, S. Ashworth, B.Z. Balázs, T. Lukács, J.P. Davim. A critical review on mechanical micro-drilling of glass and carbon fibre reinforced polymer (GFRP and CFRP) composites. Compos. Part. B: Eng. 110589 (2023)10.1016/j.compositesb.2023.110589 ↗
11. N. Tao, G. Chen, T. Yu, W. Li, L. Fan, Dual-beam laser drilling process for thick carbon fiber reinforced plastic composites plates. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 281, 116590 (2020)10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2020.116590 ↗
12. B. Varikkadinmel, A. Mahajan, I. Singh, Hole drilling in basalt-reinforced sustainable composites using abrasive waterjet for construction applications. Constr. Build. Mater. 453, 139128 (2024)10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2024.139128 ↗
13. F. Zhu, H. Zhang, K. Hu, L. Duan, K. Zhang, X. Xu, A comparative investigation on surface quality of CFRP laminates between rotary drilling and rotary ultrasonic-assisted drilling. Compos. Struct. 358, 118964 (2025)10.1016/j.compstruct.2025.118964 ↗
14. Y. Zhao, X. Yang, Y. Lu, X. Duan, Electrical discharge-mechanical hybrid drilling of micro-holes in carbon fibre-reinforced polymers. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 205, 104243 (2025)10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2024.104243 ↗
15. W. Huang, S. Cao, H.N. Li, Q. Zhou, C. Wu, D. Zhu, K. Zhuang, Tool wear in ultrasonic vibration–assisted drilling of CFRP: a comparison with conventional drilling. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 115(5), 1809–1820 (2021)10.1007/s00170-021-07198-w ↗
16. A.M. Kumar, R. Parameshwaran, R. Rajasekar, C. Moganapriya, R. Manivannan, A review on drilling of fiber-reinforced polymer composites. Mech. Compos. Mater. 58(1), 97–112 (2022)10.1007/s11029-022-10014-5 ↗
17. I. Boughdiri, K. Giasin, T. Mabrouki, R. Zitoune, Effect of cutting parameters on thrust force, torque, hole quality and dust generation during drilling of GLARE 2B laminates. Compos. Struct. 261, 113562 (2021)10.1016/j.compstruct.2021.113562 ↗
18. M. Helmi Abdul Kudus, M.M. Ratnam, H.M. Akil, Factors affecting hole quality during drilling of natural fiber-reinforced composites: A comprehensive review. J. Reinf. Plast. Compos. 40(9–10), 391–405 (2021)10.1177/0731684420970650 ↗
19. de L.E. Castro Saiki, G.F. Gomes, Understanding and mitigating delamination in composite materials: a comprehensive review. Mech. Adv. Mater. Struct. 31(30), 13147–13167 (2024)10.1080/15376494.2024.2333490 ↗
20. Y.S. Rao, N.S. Mohan, N. Shetty, B. Shivamurthy, Drilling and structural property study of multi-layered fiber and fabric reinforced polymer composite-a review. Mater. Manuf. Processes. 34(14), 1549–1579 (2019)10.1080/10426914.2019.1686522 ↗
21. S.M. Shahabaz, S. Sharma, N. Shetty, S.D. Shetty, G. MC, Influence of temperature on mechanical properties and machining of fibre reinforced polymer composites: a review. Eng. Sci. 16(8), 26–46 (2021)
22. K.K. Panchagnula, K. Palaniyandi, Drilling on fiber reinforced polymer/nanopolymer composite laminates: a review. J. Mater. Res. Technol. 7(2), 180–189 (2018)10.1016/j.jmrt.2017.06.003 ↗
23. V.V. Ahire, D.R. Pangavhane, Machining characteristics of fiber reinforced polymer matrix composites: a comprehensive review. J. Polym. Eng. 45(8), 629–648 (2025)10.1515/polyeng-2025-0032 ↗
24. T. Sathish, B. Varadhan, Enhancing drilling performance in hybrid Basalt/E-Glass fiber epoxy modified with MWCNTs+ SiO2 nanocomposites. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 136(1), 315–328 (2025)10.1007/s00170-024-14049-x ↗
25. R. Sallakhniknezhad, H. Ahmadian, T. Zhou, G. Weijia, S.K. Anantharajan, A.M. Sadoun, A. Fathy, Recent advances and applications of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) in machining processes: a review. J. Manuf. Mater. Process. 8(6), 282 (2024)
26. R.K. Thakur, K.K. Singh, Experimental investigation and optimization of abrasive water jet machining parameter on multi-walled carbon nanotube doped epoxy/carbon laminate. Measurement. 164, 108093 (2020)10.1016/j.measurement.2020.108093 ↗
27. S. David-Müzel, E.P. Bonhin, M.V. Ribeiro, E.C. Botelho, M.C.S. Alves, Furfuryl resin/CNT/carbon fiber drilling, using carbide drill coated with Balinit-Helica. Mater. Manuf. Processes. 35(10), 1096–1103 (2020)10.1080/10426914.2020.1765252 ↗
28. A. Yazdanfar, H. Shahrajabian, Experimental investigation of multi-wall carbon nanotube added epoxy resin on the EDM performance of epoxy/carbon fiber/MWCNT hybrid composites. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 116, 1801–1817 (2021)10.1007/s00170-021-07593-3 ↗
29. S.K. Yadav, A. Singh, K. Debnath, S. Grover, S. Singh, Experimental investigation and comparative study between machining of CFRP composite and CNT-mixed CFRP composite using ECDM process. J. Brazilian Soc. Mech. Sci. Eng. 45, 454 (2023)10.1007/s40430-023-04388-3 ↗
30. Y. He, M. Luo, B. Wu, C. Yao, D. Wang, Study on the cutting force responses in machining multiscale carbon nanotube/carbon fiber reinforced polymer composites. J. Manuf. Process. 95, 160–170 (2023)10.1016/j.jmapro.2023.04.012 ↗
31. B.M. Soppari, K.N. Nayani, P.R. Babu, P.H. Priya, (2023). Experimental study on the behaviour of different point angled drill bits on functionalized nano tubes reinforced carbon/epoxy composites. In B. Raj et al. (Eds.), Proceedings of ICETE 2023 (pp. 1116–1124). Atlantis Press10.2991/978-94-6463-252-1_112 ↗
32. S. Kesarwani, P. Pratap, J. Kumar, R.K. Verma, V.K. Singh, (2021). An integrated approach for machining characteristics optimization of polymer nanocomposites. Materials Today: Proceedings 44: 2638–264410.1016/j.matpr.2020.12.672 ↗
33. K. Kumar, J. Kumar, V.K. Singh, R.K. Verma, An integrated module for machinability evaluation and correlated response optimization during milling of carbon nanotube/glass fiber modified polymer composites. Multiscale Multidisciplinary Model. Experiments Des. 4, 303–318 (2021)10.1007/s41939-021-00099-1 ↗
34. K. Kumar, R.K. Verma, Measurement and evaluation of delamination factors and thrust force generation during drilling of multiwall carbon nanotube (MWCNT) modified polymer laminates. Archive Mech. Eng. 69(2), 269–300 (2022)10.24425/ame.2022.140417 ↗
35. Y. Fedai, G. Basar, H. Kırlı Akın, Multi-response optimization in drilling of MWCNTs reinforced GFRP using Gray relational analysis. Tehnički Vjesn. 29(3), 742–751 (2022)
36. K. Kumar, R.K. Verma, Using additive ratio assessment and artificial bee colony (ARAS-ABC) optimization algorithm during drilling of carbon nanomaterial/glass fiber-reinforced polymer laminated composites. Surf. Rev. Lett. 30(11), 2350074 (2023)10.1142/S0218625X23500749 ↗
37. Y. Fedai, Optimization of drilling parameters in drilling of MWCNT-reinforced GFRP nanocomposites using fuzzy AHP-weighted Taguchi-based MCDM methods. Processes. 11(10), 2872 (2023)10.3390/pr11102872 ↗
38. M. Koyunbakan, V. Eskizeybek, A. Ünüvar, A. Avcı, Experimental investigations on the drilling performance of carbon nanotubes reinforced glass/epoxy multi-scale composites. El-Cezeri J. Sci. Eng. 11(2), 160–169 (2024)
39. C. Rajeswari, E. Punna, Modelling and optimization of fabrication parameters for multi-walled carbon nanotubes-filled GFRP composites using RSM and Rao-1 algorithm. Eng. Res. Express. 6(2), 025554 (2024)10.1088/2631-8695/ad5493 ↗
40. K.P. Aveen, U.V. Nayak, K.M.P. Rao, H.T. Shivaramu, L. Neelakantha, V., C.M. Shashikumar, Optimization of drilling parameters to minimize delamination in CNT-filled GFRP composites using machine learning. Appl. Eng. Sci. 23, 100257 (2025)
41. F. Ceritbinmez, V. Özkan, G. Saracoglu, A. Yapici, MWCNTs doped GFRPs drilling: Crosscheck among holes obtained by alternative manufacturing methods. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 118(1–2), 33–41 (2022)10.1007/s00170-021-07181-5 ↗
42. F. Ceritbinmez, A. Yapıcı, An investigation of punching the MWCNTs doped composite plates by using different cutting profiles. Tehnički Vjesn. 28(2), 385–390 (2021)
43. C. Raja, M. Ramachandran, K. Ramu, A study on mechanical and drilling properties of carbon nanotubes reinforced GFRP composites. REST. J. Adv. Mech. Eng. 2(2), 1–7 (2023)10.46632/jame/5/2/1 ↗
44. K.K. Panchagnula, J.P. Sharma, K. Kalita, S. Chakraborty, CoCoSo method-based optimization of cryogenic drilling on multi-walled carbon nanotubes reinforced composites. Int. J. Interact. Des. Manuf. (IJIDeM). 17(1), 279–297 (2023)10.1007/s12008-022-00894-1 ↗
45. K.K. Panchagnula, J.P. Sharma, R. Cep, N.V.K. Jasti, K. Kalita, S. Chakraborty, Regression model-based parametric analysis of drilling of multi-walled carbon nanotubes-added glass fiber composite laminates. Mater. Res. Express. 11(1), 015301 (2024)10.1088/2053-1591/ad1129 ↗
46. S. Polat, M. Sarıhan, B. Malidarreh, R. Anas Boussaa, S. Karpuz, N., N. Kutu, (2026). ANN prediction of linear attenuation coefficients for 40MgO–30B2O3–30SiO2 system. Int. J. Appl. Sci. Radiation Res. 3(1)10.22399/ijasrar.56 ↗
47. S. Kiratli, Z. Aslan, Investigation of mechanical properties of nanoclay modified E-glass/epoxy composites. J. Compos. Mater. 57(16), 2501–2512 (2023)10.1177/00219983231171676 ↗
48. M.M. Nassar, R. Arunachalam, K.I. Alzebdeh, Machinability of natural fiber reinforced composites: a review. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 88(9), 2985–3004 (2017)10.1007/s00170-016-9010-9 ↗
49. H. Gökçe, M. Yavuz, İ. Çiftçi, An investigation into the performance of HSS drills when drilling commercially pure molybdenum. Sigma J. Eng. Nat. Sci. 38(1), 61–70 (2020)
50. J.Y. Sheikh-Ahmad, Machining of polymer composites, vol. 387355391 (Springer, New York, 2009)10.1007/978-0-387-68619-6 ↗
51. M. Aamir, M. Tolouei-Rad, K. Giasin, A. Nosrati, Recent advances in drilling of carbon fiber–reinforced polymers for aerospace applications: A review. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 105(5), 2289–2308 (2019)10.1007/s00170-019-04348-z ↗
52. A. Faraz, D. Biermann, K. Weinert, Cutting edge rounding: An innovative tool wear criterion in drilling CFRP composite laminates. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 49(15), 1185–1196 (2009)10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2009.08.002 ↗
53. P.J. Ross, (1988). Taguchi techniques for quality engineering: loss function, orthogonal experiments, parameter and tolerance design
54. I. Ciftci, H. Gökçe, Optimisation of cutting tool and cutting parameters in machining of molybdenum alloys through the Taguchi Method. J. Fac. Eng. Archit. Gazi Univ. 34(1), 201–213 (2019)
55. A.H. Kökçam, Ö. Uygun, E. Kılıçaslan, Gri ilişkisel analiz yöntemiyle optimum lastik seçimi. J. Intell. Systems: Theory Appl. 1(1), 31–35 (2018)
56. İ. Peker, B. Baki, (2011). Gri ilişkisel analiz yöntemiyle Türk sigortacılık sektöründe performans ölçümü. Int J Econ Admin Stud. 4(7)
57. W. Kose, İ. Temiz, S. Erol, Gray system approach for economic order quantity models under uncertainty. J. Gray Syst. 23(1), 71–82 (2011)
58. N. Yaşar, Thrust force modelling and surface roughness optimization in drilling of AA-7075: FEM and GRA. J. Mech. Sci. Technol. 33(10), 4771–4781 (2019)10.1007/s12206-019-0918-5 ↗
59. M. Günay, T. Meral, Modelling and multiresponse optimization for minimizing burr height, thrust force and surface roughness in drilling of ferritic stainless steel. Sādhanā. 45(1), 273 (2020)10.1007/s12046-020-01490-3 ↗
60. Da M.B. Silva, J. Wallbank, Cutting temperature: prediction and measurement methods—a review. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 88(1–3), 195–202 (1999)10.1016/S0924-0136(98)00395-1 ↗
61. J. Dörr, T. Mertens, G. Engering, M. Lahres, In-situ’temperature measurement to determine the machining potential of different tool coatings. Surf. Coat. Technol. 174, 389–392 (2003)10.1016/S0257-8972(03)00708-4 ↗
62. K. Jessy, S. Satish Kumar, D. Dinakaran, V. Seshagiri Rao, Influence of different cooling methods on drill temperature in drilling GFRP. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 76(1), 609–621 (2015)10.1007/s00170-014-6280-y ↗
63. D. O’Sullivan, M. Cotterell, Temperature measurement in single point turning. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 118(1–3), 301–308 (2001)10.1016/S0924-0136(01)00853-6 ↗
64. K. Weinert, C. Kempmann, Cutting temperatures and their effects on the machining behaviour in drilling reinforced plastic composites. Adv. Eng. Mater. 6(8), 684–689 (2004)10.1002/adem.200400025 ↗
65. S.D. Patil, P. Hatte, S.N. Khan, A.A. Desai, P.H. Yadav, (2023). Analyzing the design parameters and their influence on the tensile strength of composite layers using Taguchi technique. Materials Today: Proceedings 77: 640–64610.1016/j.matpr.2022.11.276 ↗
66. S. Kiratli, Z. Aslan, Influence of multi-walled carbon nanotubes with different diameters and lengths on the tension, shear and bending performance of glass/epoxy laminates. Polym. Bull. 79(7), 4801–4826 (2022)10.1007/s00289-021-03716-8 ↗
67. U.A. Khashaba, Drilling of polymer matrix composites: a review. J. Compos. Mater. 47(15), 1817–1832 (2013)10.1177/0021998312451609 ↗
68. J.M. Longbottom, J.D. Lanham, Cutting temperature measurement while machining–a review. Aircr. Eng. Aerosp. Technol. 77(2), 122–130 (2005)10.1108/00022660510585956 ↗
69. D. Geng, Y. Liu, Z. Shao, Z. Lu, J. Cai, X. Li, D. Zhang, Delamination formation, evaluation and suppression during drilling of composite laminates: a review. Compos. Struct. 216, 168–186 (2019)10.1016/j.compstruct.2019.02.099 ↗
70. A.A.A. Nasir, A.I. Azmi, T.C. Lih, M.S.A. Majid, Critical thrust force and critical feed rate in drilling flax fibre composites: A comparative study of various thrust force models. Compos. Part. B: Eng. 165, 222–232 (2019)10.1016/j.compositesb.2018.11.134 ↗
71. D. Kumar, K.K. Singh, R. Zitoune, Experimental investigation of delamination and surface roughness in the drilling of GFRP composite material with different drills. Adv. Manufacturing: Polym. Compos. Sci. 2(2), 47–56 (2016)
72. J. Babu, J. Philip, Experimental studies on effect of process parameters on delamination in drilling GFRP composites using Taguchi method. Procedia Mater. Sci. 6, 1131–1142 (2014)10.1016/j.mspro.2014.07.185 ↗
73. L. Gemi, S. Morkavuk, U. Köklü, Ş. Yazman, The effects of stacking sequence on drilling machinability of filament wound hybrid composite pipes: Part-2 damage analysis and surface quality. Compos. Struct. 235, 111737 (2020)10.1016/j.compstruct.2019.111737 ↗
74. S. Morkavuk, U. Köklü, M. Bağcı, L. Gemi, Cryogenic machining of carbon fiber reinforced plastic (CFRP) composites and the effects of cryogenic treatment on tensile properties: A comparative study. Compos. Part. B: Eng. 147, 1–11 (2018)10.1016/j.compositesb.2018.04.024 ↗
75. L. Gemi, U. Köklü, Ş. Yazman, S. Morkavuk, The effects of stacking sequence on drilling machinability of filament wound hybrid composite pipes: Part-1 mechanical characterization and drilling tests. Compos. Part. B: Eng. 186, 107787 (2020)10.1016/j.compositesb.2020.107787 ↗
76. D. Geng, Y. Liu, Z. Shao, M. Zhang, X. Jiang, D. Zhang, Delamination formation and suppression during rotary ultrasonic elliptical machining of CFRP. Compos. Part. B: Eng. 183, 107698 (2020)10.1016/j.compositesb.2019.107698 ↗