journal article·2022-08-20Open access

Traffic Sign Comprehension among Filipino Drivers and Nondrivers in Metro Manila

Rex Aurelius C. Robielos, Chiuhsiang Joe Lin

Applied Sciences· Volume 12· Issue 16

Abstract

The current study examined 73 existing traffic signs in Metro Manila for their matching accuracy, matching time, and cognitive design features. A total of 60 Filipinos (30 drivers and 30 nondrivers) were voluntarily recruited to perform a matching-based comprehension test. In a matching-based comprehension test, the traffic sign is matched with the most appropriate referent name which shows a clear-cut distinction between correct and incorrect answers. To assess a sign’s acceptability in a matching test, a level of at least 67% accuracy must be obtained in a comprehension test. For the matching accuracy, 27 of the 73 traffic signs did not comply with the 67% comprehension standard set by ISO 3864-1:2011. Drivers were found to have better matching accuracy for both regulatory and warning signs compared to nondrivers. Traffic signs displayed in symbols had the lowest matching accuracy and slowest matching time. When text was added to traffic signs displayed in symbols, matching accuracy and matching time improved significantly. However, signs displayed in text only obtained the highest matching accuracy and fastest matching time. The cognitive design features, which were the measurement of a sign’s design, were also assessed through their familiarity, concreteness, complexity, and semantic distance. Cognitive design features were found to be positively correlated to matching accuracy for both regulatory and warning signs, but negatively correlated to matching time for warning signs. For signs displayed in symbols, cognitive design features were also found to be correlated to matching accuracy and matching time. To improve comprehension and road safety, semantic distance, concreteness, and familiarity are the key cognitive design features which must be considered by traffic sign designers. Also, the Department of Transportation (Philippines) could adopt the matching test of this study as a mandatory retraining requirement for the renewal of a driver’s license. In addition, our matching-based comprehension test can also be applied and extended to evaluate existing traffic signs worldwide.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Safety Warnings and Signage · Human-Automation Interaction and Safety · Color perception and design

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Department of Industrial Management, National Taiwan University of Science and Technology, No. 43, Sec. 4, Keelung Rd., Da’an District, Taipei City 10607, Taiwan

References (54)

Show source-provided references
1. Effects of stimulus type, duration and location on priming of road signs: Implications for driving10.1016/j.trf.2007.08.005 ↗
2. Kraft, W.H., Homburger, W.S., and Pline, J.L. (2009). Traffic Engineering Handbook, Institute of Transportation Engineers. [6th ed.].
3. Effects of sign design features and training on comprehension of traffic signs in Taiwanese and Vietnamese user groups10.1016/j.ergon.2011.08.009 ↗
4. Comprehensibility of traffic signs among urban drivers in Turkey10.1016/j.aap.2011.11.014 ↗
5. Pedestrian Crash Trends and Potential Countermeasures from Around the World10.1016/j.aap.2010.12.007 ↗
6. Metropolitan Manila Development Authority (2017). Accomplishment Report of 2017, MMDA.
7. Traffic sign comprehension: A review of influential factors and future directions for research
8. Assessment of Fire-Safety Symbols10.1177/001872088202400108 ↗
9. The effects of age on symbol comprehension in central rail hubs in Taiwan10.1016/j.apergo.2012.02.004 ↗
10. Picture recognition improves with subsequent verbal information10.1037/0278-7393.11.3.588 ↗
11. Comprehension of traffic signs with symbolic versus text displays10.1016/j.trf.2012.12.012 ↗
12. (2012). Highways Safety Design Standards Part 2: Road Signs and Pavement Markings, Department of Public Works and Highways.
13. Warning symbols as reminders of hazards: Impact of training10.1016/j.aap.2007.11.009 ↗
14. Charlton, S.G., and Baas, P.H. (2006). Assessment of Hazard Warning Signs Used on New Zealand Roads, New Zealand Government—NZ Transport Agency.
15. The effectiveness of warning signs in hazardous work places: Cognitive and social determinants10.1016/S0003-6870(97)00047-1 ↗
16. Comprehension and memory for warning symbols: Age-related differences and impact of training10.1016/j.jsr.2003.05.003 ↗
17. Traffic sign symbol comprehension: A cross-cultural study10.1080/0014013032000121615 ↗
18. Ergonomic guidelines for traffic sign design increase sign comprehension10.1518/001872006776412298 ↗
19. A comprehension-based ergonomic redesign of Philippine road warning signs10.1016/j.ergon.2018.01.011 ↗
20. The effects of roadway environment and fatigue on sign perception10.1016/0022-4375(82)90015-9 ↗
21. Cooper, B.R. (1989). Comprehension of Traffic Signs by Drivers and Non-Drivers, Crowthorne, Transportation and Road Research Laboratory. TRRL Research Report No. 167.
22. Dewar, R., Kline, D., Scheiber, F., and Swanson, A. (1997). Symbol Signing Design for Older Drivers, Federal Highway Administration, US Department of Transportation.
23. Zakowska, L. (2001, January 5–6). Perception and Recognition of Traffic Signs in Relation to Drivers Characteristics and Safety—A Case Study in Poland. Road User Characteristics with Emphasis on Life-Styles, Quality of Life and Safety. Proceedings of the 14th ICTCT Workshop—International Cooperation of Theories and Concepts on Traffic Safety, Caserta, Italy.
24. Brucal, D.M., Canuto, A.L., Garcia, C.A., and Tangsoc, J.C. (2015, January 9–14). A Study on the Design of Regulatory Road Signs using Ergonomic Principles of Design and Comprehension. Proceedings of the 19th Triennial Congress of the IEA, Melbourne, Australia.
25. (2011). Safety Colors and Safety Signs, Part 1: Design Principles for Safety Signs and Safety Markings (Standard No. ISO 3864-1:2011).
26. Measuring symbol and icon characteristics: Norms for concreteness, complexity, meaningfulness, familiarity, and semantic distance for 239 symbols10.3758/BF03200730 ↗
27. Usability engineering: Scenario-based development of human-computer interaction
28. Comprehension of pictorial symbols: Effects of context and test method10.1518/001872098779480433 ↗
29. Dewar, R. (1999). Design and Evaluation of Public Information Symbols. Visual Information for Everyday Use: Design and Research Perspectives, CRC Press.
30. What makes an icon effective?10.1063/1.3078113 ↗
31. (2007). Graphical Symbols-Test Methods—Part 1: Methods for Testing Comprehensibility (Standard No. ISO 9186-1:2007).
32. Role of drivers’ personal characteristics in understanding traffic sign symbols10.1016/S0001-4575(01)00012-4 ↗
33. Matching performance of vehicle icons in graphical and textual formats10.1016/j.apergo.2013.11.009 ↗
34. Driver comprehension of regulatory signs, warning signs, and pavement markings
35. Dewar, R. (1994). Design and evaluation of graphic symbols. Proceedings of Public Graphics, University of Utrecht, Department of Psycholonomics.
36. Testing the effect of road traffic signs information value on driver behavior10.1177/001872089203400208 ↗
37. Picha, D.L., Hawkins, H.G., Womack, K.N., and Rhodes, L.R. (1995). Motorist Understanding of Alternative Design for Traffic Symbols. Final Report to the Federal Highway Administration, Texas Transportation Institute, Texas A&M University.
38. The effect of motion and signalling on drivers’ ability to predict intentions of other road users10.1016/j.aap.2016.07.011 ↗
39. Hazard prediction discriminates between novice and experienced drivers10.1016/j.aap.2015.10.006 ↗
40. What Does Code Red Mean?
41. Understanding industrial safety signs: Implications for occupational safety management10.1108/02635571111182809 ↗
42. Integrating Potential Users into the Development of a Medical Wrist Watch in Four Steps
43. Visual and auditory interfaces of advanced driver assistant systems for older drivers10.1007/978-3-540-70540-6_8 ↗
44. Redesign and evaluation of selected work zone sign symbols
45. The guessability of traffic signs: Effects of prospective-user factors and sign design features10.1016/j.aap.2007.03.018 ↗
46. Effects of color scheme and message lines of variable message signs on driver performance10.1016/j.aap.2009.12.002 ↗
47. Ergonomic Design Improves Cross-Cultural Road Sign Comprehension10.1016/j.trf.2021.01.015 ↗
48. Study of symbols coding in airway facilities10.1016/S0169-8141(98)00078-X ↗
49. Comprehension and retention of safety pictorials10.1080/001401397188017 ↗
50. Effects of hazardous material symbol labeling and training on comprehension according to three types of educational specialization10.1016/S0169-8141(02)00236-6 ↗
51. Education influence in traffic safety: A case study in Vietnam10.1016/j.iatssr.2011.01.004 ↗
52. The effect of context and drivers’ age on highway traffic signs comprehension10.1016/j.trf.2015.07.009 ↗
53. Improving Flex-route Transit Services with Modular Autonomous Vehicles10.1016/j.tre.2021.102331 ↗
54. Sensing Data Supported Traffic Flow Prediction via Denoising Schemes and ANN: A Comparison10.1109/JSEN.2020.3007809 ↗